Saturday, January 30, 2016

After 124 Years, the Russian and Turkish Baths Are Still a Hot Spot

A longstanding bathhouse in the East Village has found ways to attract a new generation of customers — though they tend to come only every other week.

By ANNIE CORREA NY TIMES

On a recent Monday evening, it was hard to find a bit of bench at the Russian and Turkish Baths in the East Village. It was cold out, and people crowded the saunas — young, slim and in skimpy bathing suits.

The 124-year-old bathhouse on East 10th Street has long been a New York institution, a bona fide melting pot, where the sweat of celebrities mingles with that of rabbis and taxi drivers. It’s where downtown denizens have gone to detox and discuss the deeper things of life, and where Orthodox Jewish men have gone to convene, or to hide from their wives. For much of its existence it has been a men’s club for those far beyond the age of vanity.

Now, it’s a little different.

On that Monday, the patrons were still mainly male, but rather than bellies the size of airbags, many of them had washboard abs, and the discussion turned not to aches and pains but to Tinder dates. “The hipsters come in with their Groupons, sporting their tattoos and their man buns,” Rich Trince, 50, a longtime regular, said later.

The 124-year-old bathhouse on East 10th Street in the East Village. Credit Nicole Craine for The New York Times
The fabled baths — housed in a tenement basement and frequented by Frank Sinatra and John Belushi — have been claimed by the denizens of the new New York, as shvitzing has joined shuffleboard, brewing beer and pickling as a pastime enjoyed by millennials as well as retirees.

It was inevitable that change would come to the baths, with the East Village transformed and a bathhouse renaissance in full swing — there are the Russian banya of Brooklyn, the sumptuous Spa Castle in Queens, boutique spas in Manhattan like Aire and the Great Jones Spa, with its indoor waterfall.

But at the Russian and Turkish Baths, the new order reigns just half the time.

For years, the two Russian owners, Boris Tuberman and David Shapiro, have split the bathhouse business down the middle, running it on alternate weeks. (More on that in a moment.) They share expenses and the costs of repairs, but have separate corporations. A sign in the lobby reads, “Cards for Boris and David weeks must be purchased separately.”

In the past, the arrangement was easy enough to ignore, regulars say. Every other week, a different staff appeared behind the front desk, like two casts for the same play.

But some years back, Mr. Shapiro’s son Dmitry, 42, took over his father’s shift and began offering online promotions through companies like Groupon. On his weeks, the baths “became a little less eccentric,” said Jen Emma Hertel, one of Mr. Shapiro’s front-desk clerks, as they began to fill with young Brooklyn types and thrifty tourists.

Mr. Tuberman, however, resisted Groupon — and, for that matter, the Internet. “I don’t have memberships,” he said. “I have cards which don’t expire.”

On his weeks, there are no computers behind the counter, no swipe cards. The front-desk staff, which includes the owner and three Russian-speaking managers, uses punch cards and ledger books. Mr. Tuberman, 75, even disconnects the phone.

Customers can check whose week it is on the bath’s website.

The old system of alternating weeks has had various effects. One has been to thoroughly confuse people who arrive with a Groupon on the wrong week. It has also preserved, at least half the time, something of the old world of the shvitz.

On David weeks, as they are called, there is a new crowd. But on Boris weeks, the regulars are still “vaguely Slavic, vaguely paunchy,” as Charles Kramer, a 62-year-old lawyer and a regular for decades, described it, patting his belly. “You could blink your eyes and be back.”
On a recent Boris week, Warren Odze, a Broadway musician, had returned to the baths for the first time since the early 1980s. Many things were as he recalled: A little kitchen in the lobby served Russian-Jewish fare, and below ground, in a narrow space not much longer than a subway car, customers sat in towels in a misty Turkish steam room and a piping hot Russian sauna, received platzas, or therapeutic thrashings with oak branches, and dipped into an ice-cold pool.

Mr. Odze also noted the changes. The price of a day pass had quadrupled, to $40. There was a juice bar, a women’s locker room, women. Three decades ago, it was different. “There was nothing healthy about it,” he recalled. “It was steaks and big bagels. ‘Goodfellas,’ but the Jewish version.” In the basement then, Mr. Odze said, “it was old men basking and groaning, and I was scared of all of them.”

Mr. Odze said the bathhouse had become “trendy.” Still, he said, there was a remnant of the period he remembered. “I was happy to see there were a lot of, as they say among us Jews, schlubs.”

He added: “There were these old guys, and they were just there to sweat it out. They were not shy at all to let their big guts hang out. They were like, ‘I don’t care if you’re 20 and in a bikini, get out of my way.’  ”

Bathhouses were once ubiquitous in New York, the result of a city effort in the 19th century to keep residents in teeming immigrant neighborhoods clean before most homes had hot water.

The Tenth Street Baths, as they were long known, are thought to have opened in 1892. In their prime, as bath lore has it, they were a hangout for gangsters who talked business in the saunas and so preferred deaf-mute masseurs. Vodka was served in the lobby.

By the mid-1980s, when the elder Mr. Shapiro and Mr. Tuberman bought the baths, there was still one mute masseur, but the glory days had long passed. Most bathhouses in the city had closed decades earlier; almost all of those that remained were shut down by the authorities in 1985, as AIDS swept New York, for operating as gay gathering places.

The baths on 10th Street, which had a sign proclaiming the business the “straight place,” were among the few spared, but they were in shambles.

Mr. Tuberman had arrived in New York from Leningrad. His partner came from Siberia via Uzbekistan and Europe. (David Shapiro, who is 70 and lives in the Riverdale neighborhood of the Bronx, declined a request for an interview and provided answers through his son.) The two had been introduced by a mutual acquaintance. Along with a third partner, they paid $850,000 for the baths and the five-story building, with no money down, in 1985.

After the city crackdown, they found themselves with a virtual monopoly. But “it was pretty much a flophouse,” the younger Mr. Shapiro said. The previous owner, Al Modlin, had died in 1981 while giving a platza, and the family friend who took over was overwhelmed. The roof was caving in; the linoleum floors were peeling back. Men stayed overnight on bunk beds meant for naps.

Mr. Shapiro and Mr. Tuberman changed the locks, added tile floors, fixed the roof and added a deck modeled on a dacha, or Russian country house.
Business picked up, and they bought out the third partner. But privately, the owners’ relationship grew strained. They divided the days of the week; then they began to alternate weeks. The split became public in 1992 when a sign appeared on the lockers that read, “The bath is now operated by separate owners on alternative weeks.”

Both parties were vague about the origins of the conflict. “It wasn’t a single event,” Dmitry Shapiro said. “It’s just two people who are fundamentally different. My dad is very rigid and detail-oriented. And Boris is not a man who believes in rules. I don’t think he has a process. He does things on the fly.”

Mr. Tuberman called it a “profit divorce.”

“One day I come up with the idea,” he said. “God made seven days. Why not share them?”

A 1993 article in The New York Times warned of an “uncertain future” for the bathhouse and questioned whether it could survive the owners’ unusual business arrangement.

But more than two decades later, the baths are still here, and the owners are still alternating weeks.

The secret to their survival came down to one important business decision, Mr. Tuberman said recently. “I am a fan of U.S.A. which has made a great thing,” he said. He took a pen and scribbled something on the back of a punch card.

“Nobody has made that. Nobody give that. I’ve become very successful because of the golden word.”

He slid the card over.

It read, “CO ED.”

When Mr. Tuberman and Mr. Shapiro bought the baths, there had been one all-female shift per week. The new owners gradually made nearly all days coed. After an awkward period when both sexes shared one dressing room — where “the women found interesting ways of pulling their brassieres through their sleeves,” recalled Mr. Kramer — they raised a wall of lockers, creating the cramped men’s and women’s rooms that exist today.
The owners arguably ushered in the bathing trend by turning the baths coed and making what at the time were considered prissy additions: juice, mud masks and, later, an aromatherapy room. But in recent years they seem to have made few concessions to changing tastes.

The bathhouse still looks like a hostel with a flooded basement. The staff shouts in Russian as young men appear from downstairs with arms full of wet towels. The paint on the roof deck is peeling. The chocolate-brown towels have faded to tan.

In the era of Spa Castle, it’s still Spa Tenement.

They do not offer a Golden Caviar Pore Refining Facial. But you may help yourself to the industrial-grade pink soap in the showers.

And people keep coming.

On a recent Boris week, Mr. Tuberman sat behind the counter in a blue puffer jacket. He spends his off-weeks in Miami Beach, where he has another bathhouse of the same name. But on his weeks, he returns to New York to set the heat each day and sell punch cards.

“If you try and buy a day pass, Boris will say: ‘You’re stupid from the heat! You have to buy passes!’  ” said Julian Colucci, a 25-year-old video producer. “He would sell passes to a terminally ill person.”

Downstairs, that Friday, Boris regulars sat on a bench beside the pool like patrons of an old dive bar, their arms hanging over a railing draped with wet towels.

“I’ve been coming here 40 years,” Mitch Zykofsky, 57, a retired police sergeant, said. “It’s still a mystery to this day why Boris and David had that feud, but somehow I fell into the Boris camp.”

“Boris has been like a father to me,” said Gary Hope, 48, a former boxer who recently played a drill sergeant in a Halls cough drops commercial.

Behind them, men waded into the frigid pool and turned in circles with beatific grins, arms outstretched, like polar bears.
Julia Hughes, 30, a former East Villager who had moved to Brooklyn, said: “On Boris weeks, I find the characters are a little more eccentric, a little more fun. You never know what’s going to happen.”

But by broad consensus, it was the heat that most defined a Boris week.

“On Boris’s weeks, the hots are hotter, the colds are colder,” Chris Sullivan, a 35-year-old actor, said, a claim repeated by almost all Boris loyalists, including Mr. Tuberman himself.

Mr. Shapiro, when asked about that assessment, said: “I’ll let him say it. It makes him happy.” He added: “Hotter is not better, you know.”

Both would say only that the Russian Room, the hottest of the five steam rooms and saunas, was heated to the mid- to high 190s — about the temperature recommended to slow-cook a roast.

And so which weeks are actually hotter will remain a secret of the shvitz.

The following Monday, the start of a David week, the computers were back behind the desk, along with a friendly Midwestern woman, Ms. Hertel, swiping cards. In the lobby, beneath yellowing head shots, a young Groupon customer read a book by Amanda Palmer as she waited for her friend. It was quiet.

Downstairs, though, chatter echoed through the corridor and there was, indeed, a parade of tattoos.

In the aromatherapy room, a man described a visit to a tea shop where the cheapest item was a $21 pouch of loose-leaf plum-leaf tea. Someone else said, “She touched my knee, so then I touched her knee as well.”

Beside the pool, in the same baths where mobsters are said to have once made deals, a voice rose from the steam.

“Do you know anyone in children’s books?”
In the searing Russian Room, the three tiers of benches were full, so men stood around a water trough, trying to talk casually as they dripped sweat.

A couple held hands, closed their eyes and issued a guttural om.

In the corner, two older men took in the spectacle from a top bench. One wore a traditional Russian bathing cap made of yellow felt. The other had a wiry gray beard and rubber clogs. He spoke loudly about the baths, as if to command an audience, but no one was listening.

At some point he leaned forward as if to rise, but he found his path to the trough blocked by bodies. He put his hands around his mouth.

“Young man!” he said.

Everyone looked up.

“Hand me a bucket.”

By filling the baths using online coupons, Mr. Shapiro said, he is pulling them into the 21st century.

He pointed out that they had survived the economic downturn and transformed their block, where there is now a Pilates studio, a gluten-free cafe, a water bar.

If the baths had held their own against the competition, it was because of his innovations, he said. “Boris doesn’t have an email address,” he said.

Mr. Tuberman was more philosophical. “I know the reason I am here,” he said. “Life is so difficult. Russian, Jewish, Catholic, Muslim. They all fight. They can’t get along. I am the one who brought them all together. It’s like a church, but a different church. It’s like one big meeting.”

In other words, heat it and they will come.

Mr. Shapiro agreed that the baths were about tolerating others — namely Mr. Tuberman. “He is like the crazy uncle I never had,” he said, shaking his head. “There is no other way to describe him.”

But here’s another secret from the shvitz. On one evening, a familiar face was spotted in the saunas. His hair was slicked back, his cheeks beet red from the heat. It was the younger Mr. Shapiro. On a Boris week. He smiled sheepishly.

He later explained that during his workweek, he had little time to strip down and steam. And, he added, the owners’ relationship is not as bitter as it once was. Times had changed.

But one had to wonder if on Boris weeks, surrounded by the grumbling sorts that had always been his second family, Mr. Shapiro himself didn’t feel a little more at home.

Tuesday, January 12, 2016

The Brutalism of Ted Cruz

David Brooks NY Times

In 1997, Michael Wayne Haley was arrested after stealing a calculator from Walmart. This was a crime that merited a maximum two-year prison term. But prosecutors incorrectly applied a habitual offender law. Neither the judge nor the defense lawyer caught the error and Haley was sentenced to 16 years.

Eventually, the mistake came to light and Haley tried to fix it. Ted Cruz was solicitor general of Texas at the time. Instead of just letting Haley go for time served, Cruz took the case to the Supreme Court to keep Haley in prison for the full 16 years.

Some justices were skeptical. “Is there some rule that you can’t confess error in your state?” Justice Anthony Kennedy asked. The court system did finally let Haley out of prison, after six years.
The case reveals something interesting about Cruz’s character. Ted Cruz is now running strongly among evangelical voters, especially in Iowa. But in his career and public presentation Cruz is a stranger to most of what would generally be considered the Christian virtues: humility, mercy, compassion and grace. Cruz’s behavior in the Haley case is almost the dictionary definition of pharisaism: an overzealous application of the letter of the law in a way that violates the spirit of the law, as well as fairness and mercy.

Traditionally, candidates who have attracted strong evangelical support have in part emphasized the need to lend a helping hand to the economically stressed and the least fortunate among us. Such candidates include George W. Bush, Mike Huckabee and Rick Santorum.
Senator Ted Cruz of Texas with Bob Vander Plaats, one of the most influential leaders of Iowa’s politically activist evangelicals, in Rock Rapids last week.Ted Cruz’s Diligent Courting of Evangelicals Pays Off in Iowa
Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida, far right, highlighted his background — the son of a bartender and a maid — during the Kemp Forum in Columbia, S.C., on Saturday. Mr. Rubio also noted that Gov. John Kasich of Ohio, sitting next to him, understood the challenges of struggling Americans, with a father who delivered mail.Republican Candidates, Minus Donald Trump and Ted Cruz, Play Nice at Poverty Forum
But Cruz’s speeches are marked by what you might call pagan brutalism. There is not a hint of compassion, gentleness and mercy. Instead, his speeches are marked by a long list of enemies, and vows to crush, shred, destroy, bomb them. When he is speaking in a church the contrast between the setting and the emotional tone he sets is jarring.

Cruz lays down an atmosphere of apocalyptic fear. America is heading off “the cliff to oblivion.” After one Democratic debate he said, “We’re seeing our freedoms taken away every day, and last night was an audition for who would wear the jackboot most vigorously.”

As the Republican strategist Curt Anderson observed in Politico, there’s no variation in Cruz’s rhetorical tone. As is the wont of inauthentic speakers, everything is described as a maximum existential threat.

The fact is this apocalyptic diagnosis is ridiculous. The Obama administration has done things people like me strongly disagree with. But America is in better economic shape than any other major nation on earth. Crime is down. Abortion rates are down. Fourteen million new jobs have been created in five years.

Obama has championed a liberal agenda, but he hasn’t made the country unrecognizable. In 2008, federal spending accounted for about 20.3 percent of gross domestic product. In 2015, it accounted for about 20.9 percent.

But Cruz manufactures an atmosphere of menace in which there is no room for compassion, for moderation, for anything but dismantling and counterattack. And that is what he offers. Cruz’s programmatic agenda, to the extent that it exists in his speeches, is to destroy things: destroy the I.R.S., crush the “jackals” of the E.P.A., end funding for Planned Parenthood, reverse Obama’s executive orders, make the desert glow in Syria, destroy the Iran nuclear accord.

Some of these positions I agree with, but the lack of any positive emphasis, any hint of reform conservatism, any aid for the working class, or even any humane gesture toward cooperation is striking.

Ted Cruz didn’t come up with this hard, combative and gladiatorial campaign approach in isolation. He’s always demonstrated a tendency to bend his position — whether immigration or trade — to what suits him politically. This approach works because in the wake of the Obergefell v. Hodges court decision on same-sex marriage, many evangelicals feel they are being turned into pariahs in their own nation.
Cruz exploits and exaggerates that fear. But he reacts to Obergefell in exactly the alienating and combative manner that is destined to further marginalize evangelicals, that is guaranteed to bring out fear-driven reactions and not the movement’s highest ideals.

The best conservatism balances support for free markets with a Judeo-Christian spirit of charity, compassion and solidarity. Cruz replaces this spirit with Spartan belligerence. He sows bitterness, influences his followers to lose all sense of proportion and teaches them to answer hate with hate. This Trump-Cruz conservatism looks more like tribal, blood and soil European conservatism than the pluralistic American kind.

Evangelicals and other conservatives have had their best influence on American politics when they have proceeded in a spirit of personalism — when they have answered hostility with service and emphasized the infinite dignity of each person. They have won elections as happy and hopeful warriors. Ted Cruz’s brutal, fear-driven, apocalypse-based approach is the antithesis of that.

Thursday, January 07, 2016

NATURE | NEWS FEATURE 

The physics of life Gabriel Popkin

From flocking birds to swarming molecules, physicists are seeking to understand 'active matter' — and looking for a fundamental theory of the living world.
First, Zvonimir Dogic and his students took microtubules — threadlike proteins that make up part of the cell's internal 'cytoskeleton' — and mixed them with kinesins, motor proteins that travel along these threads like trains on a track. Then the researchers suspended droplets of this cocktail in oil and supplied it with the molecular fuel known as adenosine triphosphate (ATP).
To the team's surprise and delight, the molecules organized themselves into large-scale patterns that swirled on each droplet's surface. Bundles of microtubules linked by the proteins moved together “like a person crowd-surfing at a concert”, says Dogic, a physicist at Brandeis University in Waltham, Massachusetts.

Lab-made droplets roll themselves
With these experiments, published1 in 2012, Dogic's team created a new kind of liquid crystal. Unlike the molecules in standard liquid-crystal displays, which passively form patterns in response to electric fields, Dogic's components were active. They propelled themselves, taking energy from their environment — in this case, from ATP. And they formed patterns spontaneously, thanks to the collective behaviour of thousands of units moving independently.

These are the hallmarks of systems that physicists call active matter, which have become a major subject of research in the past few years. Examples abound in the natural world — among them the leaderless but coherent flocking of birds and the flowing, structure-forming cytoskeletons of cells. They are increasingly being made in the laboratory: investigators have synthesized active matter using both biological building blocks such as microtubules, and synthetic components including micrometre-scale, light-sensitive plastic 'swimmers' that form structures when someone turns on a lamp. Production of peer-reviewed papers with 'active matter' in the title or abstract has increased from less than 10 per year a decade ago to almost 70 last year, and several international workshops have been held on the topic in the past year.

The secret of life
Researchers hope that this work will lead them to a complete, quantitative theory of active matter. Such a theory would build on physicists' century-old theory of statistical mechanics, which explains how the motion of atoms and molecules gives rise to everyday phenomena such as heat, temperature and pressure. But it could go much further, providing a mathematical framework for still-mysterious biological processes such as how cells move things around, how they create and maintain their shapes and how they divide. “We want a theory of the mechanics and statistics of living matter with a status comparable to what's already been done for collections of dead particles,” says Sriram Ramaswamy, a physicist and director of the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research's Centre for Interdisciplinary Sciences in Hyderabad, India.
It could be a while before that want is satisfied, however. Experimentalists are only beginning to gain control of active materials in the lab. Even the most enthusiastic proponents of this research admit that no one has yet produced a theory of active matter that describes the behaviour of everything from cell parts to birds. And if such a theory did exist, it's far from certain that mainstream biologists would see value in it. For biologists, the idea that living matter is active “would be just so obvious as to not really contain very much information”, says Jonathon Howard, a molecular biophysicist at Yale University in New Haven, Connecticut.

Scientists print self-assembling 'living tissue'
But that has not kept proponents from imagining applications such as self-assembling artificial tissue, self-pumping microfluidic devices and new bio-inspired materials — although researchers admit that such ideas are still far from being realized. “I think it's too early for the field to have an application, because we're still kind of astonished at what can happen,” says Andreas Bausch, a physicist at the Technical University of Munich in Germany — “but I do think the field needs somebody doing it.”
All together now
All known life forms are based on self-propelled entities uniting to create large-scale structures and movements. If this didn't happen, organisms would be limited to using much slower, passive processes such as diffusion to move DNA and proteins around inside cells or tissues, and many of life's complex structures and functions might never have evolved. Biologists and physicists have speculated for decades about the general principles of living matter, but research on cellular processes has focused on identifying the dizzying array of molecules involved, rather than on working out the principles by which they self-organize. As a result, what is now known as active-matter research did not really get under way until the mid-1990s.

The tiniest Lego: a tale of nanoscale motors, rotors, switches and pumps
One of the most influential early experiments was conducted by the team of Stanislas Leibler, a biophysicist who was then at Princeton University in New Jersey and is now at the Rockefeller University in New York. The group was among the first to show that complex, life-like structures could self-assemble from microtubules and a few proteins supplied with ATP2. Around the same time, an influential model of active matter was being developed by Tamás Vicsek, a theoretical biophysicist at Eötvös Loránd University in Budapest. In the early 1990s, Vicsek was trying to account for the collective motions of bird flocks, bacterial colonies and cytoskeleton components when he realized that no existing theory would work. “It's not like equilibrium statistical mechanics, where you take a book and you find what to do,” says physicist Jean-François Joanny of the Curie Institute in Paris.
Instead, Vicsek found a starting point in a model of magnetic materials developed in 1928 by German physicist Werner Heisenberg. Heisenberg imagined each atom as a freely rotating bar magnet, and found that large-scale magnetism emerges when interactions between these atomic magnets cause the majority of them to align. To explain active matter, Vicsek replaced the tiny magnets with moving 'arrows' symbolizing particles with velocities that aligned with the average velocity of their neighbours — albeit with a certain amount of random error. That led to what is now known as Vicsek's flocking model3. His simulations showed that when enough arrows were packed into a small enough space, they began to move in patterns that closely resembled the familiar movements of bird flocks and fish schools (see 'Smart swarms').
“I got excited,” recalls Vicsek, whose 1995 paper3 on the model has received more than 3,500 citations. “I was walking up and down the corridor and told people I had designed the moving version of the Heisenberg model.”

One physicist attracted to this idea was John Toner, who heard Vicsek give a talk on it in 1994. Toner, now at the University of Oregon in Eugene, saw that Vicsek's swarming arrows could be modelled as a continuous fluid. He took the standard equations for hydrodynamics, which describe fluid flow in everything from tea kettles to oceans, and modified them to account for how individual particles use energy4. Toner's fluid model and Vicsek's discrete-particle model gave essentially the same predictions for a wide range of phenomena, and launched a cottage industry of active-matter simulations.
Precision formation flight astounds scientists
There was only one problem. Whereas the number of simulations was skyrocketing, says physicist Denis Bartolo of the École Normale Supérieure in Lyons, France, “the number of quantitative experiments was constant and very close to zero”. Practical work was challenging: no one could hope to do controlled experiments with 10,000 real birds or fish. And at the microscopic scale, few scientists were familiar with both the necessary theoretical work — being published mainly in physics journals — and the biological lab techniques needed to purify cellular components.

Practical magic
Only in the late 2000s did the theoretical and experimental pieces begin coming together. Bausch led one of the first precise, quantitative experiments. He and his colleagues mixed actin, a filament that forms most of the cytoskeleton of complex cells, with myosin, a molecular motor that 'walks' on actin and makes muscles contract. The researchers added myosin's natural fuel, ATP, then put the mixture on a microscope slide and watched. “We didn't do anything; we just added the stuff,” Bausch says. At low concentrations, the actin filaments swam around without recognizable order. But at higher densities, they formed pulsating clusters, swirls and bands. Bausch and his colleagues immediately recognized and quantified phase transitions of the kind that Vicsek and others had predicted. Their 2010 paper5 helped to ignite the experimental active-matter field.
Among the studies that followed were Dogic's 2012 microtubule experiments1, which used another walking protein, kinesin. The resulting patterns were much more complex and dynamic than the ones Bausch saw: the flowing microtubules looked like fingerprint whorls in motion. Dogic and his team also noticed that the orderly alignment of this flow would occasionally break down and produce 'defects': discontinuities in the pattern that resemble converging longitude lines at the North and South poles. These defects were dynamic, moving around like self-propelled particles.

No theory at the time could account for this behaviour. But in 2014, Dogic teamed up with Bausch and physicist Cristina Marchetti of Syracuse University in New York to describe the behaviour of active liquid crystals swirling on spherical vesicles in terms of the movement of defects rather than of individual crystal elements6. Furthermore, the group found that it could tune the defects' motion by adjusting the vesicle's diameter and surface tension, suggesting a possible way to control an active crystal.
“We're still kind of astonished at what can happen.”
Dogic and his students are now trying to do just that. By studying the spontaneous flows of microtubules and proteins confined in small, doughnut-shaped containers, they hope to lay the groundwork for a self-pumping fluid that could move molecules around in microfluidic devices similar to those that are becoming increasingly common in experimental biology, medicine and industry. Active matter “changes our ideas of what materials can do”, says Dogic.
But any industrial application will have to overcome at least one major roadblock. The biological materials currently used in active-matter experiments are expensive and time-consuming to purify — Dogic's microtubules come from cow brains, and Bausch uses actin from rabbit muscle — and they last only a short time in the lab. Until a cheap, robust, off-the-shelf source of active-matter materials can be found, commercial use is unlikely, says Bausch.

Autonomous drones flock like birds
Advances in synthetic active materials may show the way forward. In 2013, New York University physicist Paul Chaikin and his colleagues described making particles of haematite, an iron oxide mineral, inside a spherical polymer7. When the scientists placed these 'swimmers' in a solution of hydrogen peroxide and exposed them to blue light, a chemical reaction caused the particles to move around spontaneously, clumping and unclumping like groups of people at a cocktail party.
In 2013, Bartolo and his colleagues reported large-scale flows using even simpler plastic spheres in a conducting fluid8. When the researchers turned on an electric field, the spheres began rotating in random directions. At high enough densities, interactions between nearby spheres caused them to spontaneously roll, flock-like, in the same direction.
Such lab-made materials remain primitive, however, compared with those produced in cells by 4 billion years of evolution. Dogic notes that the kinesins he uses are much more efficient than any human-made motors at converting energy to motion. And Bartolo is also quick to discourage talk of short-term pay-offs. “I'm not targeting a specific application,” he says of his rotating plastic spheres.

Possible applications aside, active matter excites scientists because it so closely resembles the most complex self-organizing systems known: living organisms. In 2011, Dogic and his colleagues reported9 that microtubule bundles anchored at one end to air bubbles on a microscope slide beat in synchronized, wave-like patterns eerily reminiscent of the hair-like cilia and flagella that protrude from the surfaces of some cells. And in his 2012 paper1, he noted a striking similarity between his microtubule flows and cytoplasmic streaming, a process in which cytoskeletal filaments team up to whisk a cell's contents around like “a giant washing machine”, he says.

Researchers create 1,000-robot swarm
The resemblance between lab-prepared active matter and living things can be uncanny, agrees Jennifer Ross, a physicist at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. At talks, she has shown videos of spherical microtubule–kinesin systems and asked audience members whether they think they are seeing a real cell. “Whenever I present these to cell biologists in particular, they are always fooled,” she says.
But something can look and act like a living organism without actually following the same rules, cautions Howard. He points out that Dogic's group created something that looks and acts very much like a cilium or flagellum with its multitude of proteins — but that may, in fact, work very differently. “There's something in there about the underlying mechanism, but it's extremely abstract,” he says.
Is it enough?

To probe whether active-matter theory can reveal biological mechanisms, Daniel Needleman, a biophysicist at Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, studied the spindle: a microtubule-based structure that controls the separation of chromosomes during cell division. He wanted to test the idea, suggested by earlier theories and experiments, that short-range microtubule–kinesin interactions by themselves were sufficient to yield spindle-like structures. He first used sophisticated microscopes to examine extracts from frog egg cells, quantifying microtubule density, orientation and stresses during spindle formation. “It really was not clear at all until Dan came along that you could measure all these things,” says Howard.
Needleman then merged his measurements with models of how active matter self-organizes. In 2014, he and Jan Brugués, a biologist at the Max Planck Institute of Molecular Cell Biology and Genetics in Dresden, Germany, reported that, consistent with theory, the interactions they observed among closely spaced microtubules are enough to produce the spindle and keep it stable10. “People have argued that you need more complex processes,” says Needleman. “But the fact that one can understand so much of the spindle without invoking any of that shows that it's certainly not necessary.”

Mathematical time law governs crowd flow
Others are using ideas from active matter to probe how large numbers of cells organize in processes such as tissue growth, wound healing and the spread of tumours. Theorists including Marchetti, Joanny and Frank Jülicher of the Max Planck Institute for the Physics of Complex Systems in Dresden have modelled tissues11 and tumours12 as flowing cells that self-organize through short-range cell-to-cell interactions rather than chemical signals. Experimentalists are testing such ideas, for instance, by showing that active-matter theory can help to describe cell organization in a developing fruit-fly wing13.
Some biologists hope that such studies will reveal the fundamental principles that govern how cells divide, take shape or move. “It's like Linnaean classification before Darwin came along,” says biologist Tony Hyman of the Max Planck Institute of Molecular Cell Biology and Genetics. “We've got all these molecules, just like they had all those species, and we need to put some kind of order, some kind of reason behind it all.” Active matter, Hyman thinks, could provide that reason.

But even enthusiasts admit that mainstream biologists may need convincing. “We used to get a lot of papers rejected at the beginning,” says Hyman — in part because the manuscripts' heavy use of mathematics made it hard to find reviewers. Even the phrase 'active matter' may hinder communication, adds Howard. “It's kind of a physics-y term.”
Still, Howard and Hyman hope that acceptance will be aided by increasing convergence between fields. Among biologists, says Hyman, “I think the new generation coming along will be trained in physics from the beginning.”
And that's good, adds Stephan Grill, a biophysicist at the Technical University of Dresden, because progress in active matter calls for scientists who are at the cutting edge of both physics and biology. “The pot of gold is at the interface,” he says, “but you have to push both fields to their limits.”

Wednesday, December 30, 2015

Cleveland’s Terrible Stain

By THE NY TIMES EDITORIAL BOARD

Tamir Rice of Cleveland would be alive today had he been a white 12-year-old playing with a toy gun in just about any middle-class neighborhood in the country on the afternoon of Nov. 22, 2014.

But Tamir, who was shot to death by a white police officer that day, had the misfortune of being black in a poor area of Cleveland, where the police have historically behaved as an occupying force that shoots first and asks questions later. To grow up black and male in such a place is to live a highly circumscribed life, hemmed in by forces that deny your humanity and conspire to kill you.

Those forces hovered over the proceedings on Monday when a grand jury declined to indict Officer Timothy Loehmann in the killing and Timothy McGinty, the Cuyahoga County prosecutor, explained why he had asked the grand jurors to not bring charges. Mr. McGinty described the events leading up to Tamir’s death as tragic series of errors and “miscommunications” that began when a 911 caller said a male who was “probably a juvenile” was waving a “probably fake” gun at people in a park.

The fact that those caveats never reached Officer Loehmann — who shot the child within seconds of arriving on the scene — was more than just an administrative misstep. It reflects an utter disregard for the lives of the city’s black residents. That disregard pervades every aspect of this case and begins with the fact that the department failed to even review Officer Loehmann’s work history before giving him the power of life and death over the citizens of Cleveland. Had the department done so, it would have found that Officer Loehmann had quit a suburban police department where he had showed a “dangerous loss of composure” during firearms training and was found to be emotionally unfit for the stress of the job.

Officer Loehmann joined a police department that itself had acquired a well-documented reputation for wanton violence and for shooting at people who posed no threat to the police or others. In a particularly striking event, documented by the Justice Department last year, officers mistook the sound of a car backfiring for a gunshot. They chased down and fired at the vehicle 137 times, killing two occupants who turned out to be unarmed.

The lengthy Justice Department report shows clearly why the black community viewed the Cleveland police as dangerous and profoundly out of control. In May, the Police Department entered an agreement with the Justice Department, enforceable by the courts, under which it is to adopt sweeping reforms.
The Police Department’s disregard for life was fully evident in the way the officers behaved after shooting Tamir. A surveillance video shows them standing by the child for four minutes without giving medical assistance, which was finally provided by an F.B.I. agent who happened to be in the neighborhood. Officer Frank Garmback, Officer Loehmann’s partner, nonetheless tackled the wounded boy’s 14-year-old sister as she tried to rush to his side. One can only imagine her suffering as she watched in handcuffs from the back seat of the squad car while her brother lay bleeding on the ground.

In addition to portraying the killing as a result of a tragic misunderstanding, prosecutors have also suggested the officer’s decision to kill Tamir was shaped by the fact that the surrounding neighborhood had a history of violence and that the boy appeared to be older than 12 because he was big for his age.

These arguments sidestep the history of violent, discriminatory police actions that led up to this boy’s death. They also have the reprehensible effect of shifting the responsibility for this death onto the shoulders of this very young victim.

Tuesday, December 29, 2015

2 Bankers Charged With Creating A.T.M. Cards to Steal From Accounts

By STEPHANIE CLIFFORD NY TIMES



The Restoration Plaza branch of Chase on Fulton Street in the Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood of Brooklyn. Two Chase bankers who worked in the neighborhood and two other men were charged this month with stealing from accounts.

The 15 JPMorgan Chase bank accounts had a few things in common: They had high balances, there was little activity on them and they belonged to elderly clients — indeed, at least eight were dead.

And all 15 of the accounts got regular cash infusions, thanks to direct deposits from the Social Security Administration.

That caught the eye of two private bankers who worked at a Bedford-Stuyvesant branch of JPMorgan Chase, Jonathan Francis and Dion Allison, according to an indictment filed this month in State Supreme Court in Brooklyn. Creating cards for automated teller machines and forged documents, the men and their accomplices withdrew about $400,000 from the accounts over two years, according to the indictment.

The New York attorney general, Eric T. Schneiderman, warned in June that bank tellers and other employees have easy access to customer data, and had committed fraud using the data on multiple occasions.

In this case, prosecutors for the Brooklyn district attorney’s office charged in an indictment, the bankers could not only gain access to but also issue A.T.M. cards for the 15 accounts, without the account holder’s consent.

Mr. Allison, 30, and Mr. Francis, 27, created bank cards for several of the dormant accounts. (While prosecutors believe most, if not all, of the account holders have died, benefit checks continued to be deposited because of faulty reporting to the Social Security Administration.)

With two friends, Gregory Desrameaux, 24, and Kery Phillips, 40, the men then withdrew most of the stolen money, about $300,000, by using A.T.M.s around New York City, according to the indictment. Some withdrawals were as small as $200; some were up to $2,000, the daily limit for A.T.M. withdrawals for some Chase accounts.

In April 2013 alone, members of the group made withdrawals on 26 of 30 days, according to the indictment. One night at a Chase branch at Nostrand and Church Avenues, they withdrew $1,000 from one account; 49 seconds later, group members took out $1,000 from a different account.

By May of that year, people in the group had created fake power of attorney documents. That gave Mr. Phillips control of four of the dormant accounts, Adam Zion, an assistant district attorney, said in court on Monday. This allowed Mr. Phillips to withdraw much more money than the daily A.T.M. limit, up to $9,500 at a time, through a teller.

In another example of the scheme, in February 2013, according to the indictment, Mr. Allison created a bank card for one account. That May, at a Chase branch on Flatbush Avenue, Mr. Phillips turned in fake power of attorney documents giving him control of the account. The same day, prosecutors said, Mr. Phillips withdrew through a teller $49,929.91 — everything that remained — from the account.

JPMorgan Chase has already faced accusations of fraud among staff members this year. In April, an investment adviser, Michael Oppenheim, was charged in Federal District Court in Manhattan with stealing $20 million from seven of the bank’s clients.

Also in April, another employee, Peter Persaud, who worked at a Chase branch in Brooklyn, was accused of selling customer data — including account numbers, Social Security numbers, addresses and dates of birth — to an informant and an undercover officer. Mr. Persaud was charged with fraud and identity theft in Federal District Court in Brooklyn.

Lauren Ryan, a spokeswoman for JPMorgan Chase, said the company had been “working closely with the authorities and the Social Security Administration” in the current fraud case.

The four men listed in the current indictment have been charged with conspiracy, grand larceny and falsifying business records.

On Monday, Mr. Allison was arraigned before Justice Cassandra M. Mullen in State Supreme Court in Brooklyn. Mr. Zion, the prosecutor, said that Mr. Allison searched for and maintained the targeted accounts, and issued and used some of the cards.

He had told Chase investigators that he had looked for high-value accounts, issued and used the A.T.M. cards, sold some of the cards and account data, and worked with Mr. Francis on the scheme, Mr. Zion said. Also, he had logged onto the Chase system with his co-workers’ credentials when they were away from their desks, according to Mr. Zion.

Prosecutors requested $100,000 bail; Justice Mullen released him on $25,000 bond. Mr. Francis and Mr. Desrameaux were arraigned earlier this month.

Mr. Allison’s lawyer did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Douglas Rankin, the lawyer for Mr. Francis, said that his client denied the allegations, and that he no longer worked at Chase and “left on his own before this became an issue.” David Walensky, the lawyer for Mr. Desrameaux, said his client denied involvement in the scheme.

Mr. Phillips is still at large, according to a news release from the district attorney’s office.

Monday, December 28, 2015

Cleveland Officer Will Not Face Charges in Tamir Rice Shooting Death

By MITCH SMITH NY TIMES

Timothy J. McGinty, the Cuyahoga county prosecutor, announced on Monday that the Cleveland police officer who fatally shot Tamir Rice last year will not face criminal charges.
The Cleveland police officer who fatally shot 12-year-old Tamir Rice last year will not face state criminal charges, the Cuyahoga County prosecutor’s office announced Monday.

The decision by grand jurors was the end of a lengthy investigation that was criticized by Tamir’s family and by activists, who called the shooting senseless and said the officer should have been charged with murder months ago.

Tamir, who was black, was carrying a replica gun outside a recreation center when someone called 911. The caller cautioned that Tamir was probably a juvenile and that the weapon was “probably fake,” but that information was not relayed to the two officers who responded, Timothy Loehmann and Frank Garmback.


Surveillance video, which has been widely circulated online, showed Officer Garmback pulling the police cruiser within a few feet of Tamir, and Officer Loehmann, who is white, stepping out of the car and almost immediately firing his gun. Tamir died hours later. His partner, Officer Garmback, was also not indicted.

Timothy J. McGinty, the county prosecutor, who made the announcement at a news conference, said that while “this was a perfect storm of human error,” the evidence considered by a grand jury over two months “did not constitute criminal action by police.” He noted that the law gives the benefit of the doubt to a police officer “who must make a split second decision.”

Mr. McGinty said it was “indisputable” that Tamir was drawing the weapon from his waistband when he was shot — either to hand it over to the officers or to show them that it was not a real firearm. But Mr. McGinty said there was no way for the officers to know that as they pulled up.

He said he “appreciated the sincere emotion and concern of all citizens” but asked the community to “respect the process.”

In a statement, Gov. John R. Kasich said that he understood “how this decision will leave many people asking themselves if justice was served,” but urged residents not to “give in to anger and frustration and let it divide us.”

A statement from the office of Jonathan S. Abady, a lawyer representing the Rice family, said Tamir’s relatives were “saddened and disappointed by this outcome — but not surprised.”

“It has been clear for months now that Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Timothy McGinty was abusing and manipulating the grand jury process to orchestrate a vote against indictment,” the statement said. “Even though video shows the police shooting Tamir in less than one second, Prosecutor McGinty hired so-called expert witnesses to try to exonerate the officers and tell the grand jury their conduct was reasonable and justified.”

Tamir was shot on Nov. 22, 2014, two days before a grand jury in Missouri declined to indict the white Ferguson police officer who fatally shot Michael Brown, an unarmed black 18-year-old. Though Cleveland did not experience protests as large or frequent as in Ferguson, Tamir’s death infuriated demonstrators across the country, and the case has become among the most prominent in a national debate over race and policing.

The official investigation into Tamir’s death moved slowly, with the county sheriff’s office taking over for the police department, and then the prosecutor’s office conducting its own inquiry after the sheriff’s inquiry concluded. Fed up with the pace, some activists used an obscure provision of Ohio law to seek the arrest of the two officers. Though a judge found that probable cause existed for some charges, neither officer was arrested.

Mr. McGinty released a redacted version of the sheriff’s investigation months ago, and in recent months has published three independent reports by use-of-force analysts who found that Officer Loehmann had acted reasonably in shooting Tamir.

Mr. McGinty, who commissioned the reports but said they would not taint the fairness of the grand jury process, was criticized by Tamir’s family, who suggested that the investigation was rigged and that an indictment was all but impossible.

The Rice family also commissioned outside reports on the shooting, which found that the shooting was unjustified and that the officers used poor tactics in responding to the scene.

Neither Officer Garmback nor Officer Loehmann has spoken publicly about the shooting, though both men read statements to grand jurors about their actions that day. Officer Loehmann told the grand jury that he fired out of fear for his safety after Tamir reached into his waistband and grabbed the replica gun, which he believed to be real.

Tamir’s family has questioned Officer Loehmann’s account of the shooting, and has sued the city and both officers in federal court.

Since Tamir’s death, questions have been raised about Officer Loehmann’s qualifications and about the Cleveland police’s standards on the use of force. Records show that Officer Loehmann resigned from another Ohio police department after a “dangerous loss of composure” during firearms training. The Cleveland police did not review that department’s personnel file before offering Officer Loehmann a job.

For years, the Cleveland police have been criticized for being too aggressive in its use of force, and for broader failures in management, record keeping and training. In May, the city agreed to a sweeping consent decree with the Justice Department that required broad changes in how officers use and report force, and which placed the police under the supervision of an independent monitor.

Tamir is among several black people whose deaths at the hands of the Cleveland police have raised questions in recent years. In 2012, 13 Cleveland officers fired a combined 137 rounds at Timothy Russell and Malissa Williams, both unarmed, after the car Mr. Russell was driving fled police. One officer was charged with manslaughter in the case, but was acquitted in May at a bench trial. Last November, Tanisha Anderson, a 37-year-old black woman said to have suffered from mental illness, lost consciousness and died in police custody after she was placed facedown on the pavement. An investigation into her death is continuing.

Mr. McGinty presents evidence in all fatal police encounters to a grand jury, but some activists have questioned the fairness of the process, and have noted that indictments are generally unlikely unless one is sought by a prosecutor.

In the Rice case, family lawyers have said for months that they have little confidence that Mr. McGinty wanted the officers charged. The lawyers have called for a special prosecutor to take over the case, and have asked the Justice Department to investigate.

Sunday, December 27, 2015

Stylish, Tenacious Defender

Character Study

By COREY KILGANNON NY Times

Photo

Mario F. Gallucci, 51, outside the Richmond County Courthouse in St. George on Staten Island. Credit Nicole Craine for The New York Times


Mario F. Gallucci was at it again, throwing a curveball at a witness on the stand in a Staten Island courtroom.

“Objection,” said the prosecutor, rising to her feet.

“She’s right,” a smiling Mr. Gallucci said in response to the prosecutor’s protest, which was not over a point of law but rather of Mr. Gallucci’s complimenting the suit worn by the detective on the stand, whom Mr. Gallucci was trying to cross up.

Mr. Gallucci, 51, was defending a local teenager charged with four others in the beating and robbing of another teenager. Mr. Gallucci lowered his usual $20,000 retainer to take the case on good faith, although it is hardly the high-profile type of case he is known for on Staten Island.
Questioning the arresting officers and hoping to elicit discrepancies, the other defendants’ lawyers read from notepads at a lectern. But Mr. Gallucci paced around theatrically, circled the prosecutor’s desk and adopted a jocular tone borrowed from the “My Cousin Vinny” legal playbook.
He is known for his courtroom theatrics and his sartorial style.

“People know Mario Gallucci for the way he dresses,” said Mr. Gallucci, narrating his own profile.

He keeps 150 ties on a rotating rack at home next to his array of nearly two dozen designer suits tailored to fit his 5-foot, 6-inch powerlifter’s build.

Today’s suit was a charcoal Hickey Freeman, which he wore over a custom-made shirt with monogrammed cuffs.

During the hearing, Mr. Gallucci got one detective to admit hiring his client repeatedly in the past, to serve as “filler in a lineup” for unrelated arrests, at $20 an appearance.

Afterward, he walked through the courthouse, fist-bumping court employees, who enjoy the Christmas cannolis that Mr. Gallucci is known for distributing each December.

In other circles, he is reviled for defending accused wife-killers, husband-killers, baby-killers and, in the current case of Eric Bellucci, an accused parents-killer. Mr. Bellucci is accused of stabbing his mother and father to death in their Staten Island home in 2010.

Mr. Gallucci, who was assigned the case by court officials, advised Mr. Bellucci to plead insanity. Mr. Bellucci objected and told Mr. Gallucci in open court that he would have him shot unless Mr. Gallucci helped him argue self-defense instead. Nevertheless, the case is proceeding, with the Bellucci-Gallucci pairing still intact.

Then there is the New Jersey police officer charged with driving drunk and getting into a wrong-way crash last March that killed two passengers, after the group left a strip club.

Mr. Gallucci is demanding a blood test to determine whether strippers may have slipped the defendant a dose of a date-rape drug before he got behind the wheel.

Addressing his critics, Mr. Gallucci smiled broadly and said that even the most heinous of defendants “didn’t kill anybody till the jury convicts them.”

“Fifty percent of the people hate what I do, and the other 50 percent respect the fact that I defend the Constitution,” he said. “But even that first group, I’m the first person they call when their loved one gets into trouble.”

Mr. Gallucci lives in Marlboro Township, N.J., with his wife and three teenage children.

Originally from Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, he moved with his family to Staten Island when he was 4. He went to Monsignor Farrell High School there and attended the State University of New York at Brockport, where he played second base on the baseball team and took Staten Island Italian cooking to his upstate dormitory, preparing his mother’s lasagna and baked ziti dishes for dorm-mates.

After attending Vermont Law School and working as a prosecutor for the Staten Island district attorney, he practiced civil litigation and then criminal law, and joined a pair of high school pals to form Helbock, Nappa & Gallucci, whose office is on what else but Victory Boulevard.

His love of the gourmet and pampered life helped land him and a law associate, Lou Gelormino, a reality show, “Partners in Crime,” for the USA Network in 2014.

Mr. Gallucci gets regular manicures and pedicures. He is proud of his legal record and his cooking, noting that his meatballs finished second only to those of Big Ang, another Staten Island fixture, in a charity meatball challenge.

He was once so obsessed with finding out where his father, John, bought his lauded cannolis that he had his private investigator tail his dad on a pastry run.

Not every legal defense happens in court, he said, recounting the time in 2014 that he helped a client who had been partying with a group at the Hilton Garden Inn. A woman in the group wobbled away wearing the red ruby replica slippers from the “Wizard of Oz” on display in the lobby. Mr. Gallucci brokered their prompt return with no arrest.

Mr. Gallucci also represented Michael Mastromarino, a New Jersey dentist who masterminded the harvesting of body parts from more than 1,000 corpses in the early 2000s, including the body of Alistair Cooke, the British journalist and former host of “Masterpiece Theater.”

Mr. Mastromarino pleaded guilty in 2008, after which Mr. Gallucci allowed that his client “decided to cut corners” after starting the practice legally.

Mr. Mastromarino wound up dying of bone cancer, which Mr. Gallucci noted as irony. Before that, Mr. Gallucci would visit him upstate in prison and would take Italian food to correction officers to help ease access to his client.

“I’d bring Italian heroes, capicola, prosciutto,” he said. “They don’t get that stuff upstate.”

Thursday, December 24, 2015

Fernande Grudet


Under the name 'Madame Claude' Gurdet operated a deluxe call-girl ring in Paris in the 1960s and ’70s that attracted the patronage of world leaders, business executives and playboys and made her a byword for sophisticated sex, died on Saturday in Nice, France. She was 92.

The news agency Agence France-Presse reported the death on Tuesday.

Ms. Grudet, a woman of modest background from the Anjou region, arrived in Paris in the 1950s. After working a series of menial jobs, one of which may have been selling sex on the streets, she decided that the managerial side of the business suited her talents.

“Two things in life sell,” she once said. “Food and sex. And I was not meant to be a chef.”

Precisely how she built her business remains a mystery, despite two memoirs, larded with colorful and eminently uncheckable stories. But build it she did, grooming a finishing school’s worth of beautiful young women, many of them foreign, from the fringes of the film and fashion worlds, with a sprinkling of students looking for extra cash and housewives looking for adventure in the manner of Catherine Deneuve in “Belle de Jour.”

Ms. Grudet zeroed in on “failed models and actresses, the ones who just missed the cut,” the high-society columnist Taki Theodoracopulos told William Stadiem, who spent many years interviewing Ms. Grudet for a book that never materialized, but that did yield an article for Vanity Fair last year. “But just because they failed in these impossible professions didn’t mean they weren’t beautiful, fabulous.”

Ms. Grudet liked to call her charges “swans”; clients referred to them as “Claude girls.” The term “prostitute,” she once said, “was revolting and denigrating.”

She was choosy: Only one in 20 candidates made the grade. Requirements included beauty — plastic surgery could be arranged — poise and a familiarity with history, literature and current events. Also, talent in bed. This was assessed by Ms. Grudet’s testers, male acquaintances who took candidates for a trial run and reported back to her.

Working with nothing more than a notebook and a telephone, Ms. Grudet received calls with a terse “Allô oui,” made polite small talk and then got down to prices: up to 1,000 francs for a night of bliss — about $200 in 1965, or $1,500 today.

Ms. Grudet kept 25 or 30 percent (accounts vary) of the young women’s earnings. Many of her “Claude girls” went on to find success in film, fashion or business. Quite a few married rich clients.

In 1975, the French tax authorities, who had begun taking an interest in Ms. Grudet’s business, estimated that she was taking in 100,000 to 140,000 francs a month. Her clients, whom she called “friends,” were a catalog of the rich and famous.

The soul of discretion in her heyday, Ms. Grudet became a heavy name-dropper when the time came to tell her life story, which she did in two memoirs: “Allô Oui, or the Memoirs of Madame Claude” (1975), written with Jacques Quoirez, the brother of her good friend Françoise Sagan and one of her testers; and “Madam,” published in 1994 under the name Claude Grudet.

By her account, the “friends” included John F. Kennedy, the shah of Iran, Muammar el-Qaddafi, Gianni Agnelli, Moshe Dayan, Marc Chagall, Rex Harrison and King Hussein of Jordan, who, she said, once told a Claude girl: “You and I are in the same business. We have to smile even when we don’t feel like it.”

Kennedy came to her with a special request, Ms. Grudet told Mr. Stadiem. He wanted a look-alike of his wife, Jacqueline, “but hot.”

Ms. Grudet aimed to please, within limits. A client requesting a dead body, still warm, was rebuffed, she said. Still, breathless need on the other end of the telephone line was music to her ears.

“It was so exciting to hear a millionaire or a head of state ask, in a little boy’s voice, for the one thing that only you could provide,” she once said.

Fernande Grudet was born in Angers, in western France, on July 6, 1923. Her father, who died of cancer when she was 18, kept a cafe and helped make ends meet by selling sandwiches from a cart at the train station. After graduating from Catholic schools, she made her way to occupied Paris during World War II.

She claimed to have worked as a saleswoman at Les Halles, the central food market, and as a door-to-door Bible saleswoman. She also told various people at various times that she had joined the Resistance and had been deported to Ravensbrück, the women’s concentration camp. Even friends did not know what to believe. She also said that she came from a wealthy family.

In 1958, she set up shop as a “mère maquerelle,” or “mother pimp,” as the press often referred to her, using a term she detested. She took pride in running a five-star operation and presented a well-maintained facade to the world. Meeting her for the first time, Mr. Stadiem described her as “tiny, blond, perfectly coifed and Chanel-clad.” Every morning at 8:30, she paid a visit to the hairdresser, who opened shop early for her.

The French authorities allowed her to operate undisturbed — perhaps, some theorized, because she passed along information about some of her more interesting “friends.”

After Valéry Giscard d’Estaing came to power in 1974, the climate changed. Charged with tax evasion, she was presented with a bill for 11 million francs.

In 1977, she fled to the United States and ended up in Los Angeles, where she opened an unsuccessful pastry shop and, some of her friends suspected, returned to her old trade in a small way. In the mid-1980s, she returned to France, where she bought a sheep farm by Cahors, near the home of Ms. Sagan, and tried to keep a low profile. She was arrested on the outstanding tax charges and sentenced to a short prison term.

After being released, she returned to Paris and, hoping to build a retirement nest egg, started another call-girl network — a small one with perhaps 20 “swans.” In 1992, she was arrested again, spent six months in prison awaiting trial and, after being found guilty and fined one million francs, was released.

After her trial, she became, for a time, a highly visible figure, publishing a memoir and giving interviews to promote her video on the art of seduction. She spent her final years in penury in Nice.

Her legend inspired several films, some watchable, others not. In the mid-1970s, French audiences enjoyed two Madame Claude films, “Madame Claude” — directed by Just Jaeckin, best known for the soft-pornography film “Emmanuelle” — and “The Pink Telephone.” “Madame Claude” was released in the United States as “The French Woman,” with a poster that proclaimed: “The Arab Prince, the Japanese Diplomat, the Greek Tycoon, the C.I.A. Bureau Chief — She Possessed Them All!”

Françoise Fabian, who played the title role in Mr. Jaeckin’s film, got to know Ms. Grudet well. She did not like what she saw. Behind the polished image of “swans” and “friends,” she said, was a cold, calculating business mind.

“She was like a slave driver in the American South,” Ms. Fabian told Mr. Stadiem. “Once she took a girl on, the makeover put the girl in debt, because Claude paid all the bills to Dior, Vuitton, to the hairdressers, to the doctors, and the girls had to work to pay them off. It was sexual indentured servitude.”


Mrs Grudet was always kind to important world leaders. She delighted in sending fabulous rich chocolate Brownies to those she admired. In recent years she sent Brownies to President Obama, Vladimir Putun and Pope Francis. It's been reported she once had a serious crush on President Jimmy Carter, who received peanut butter Brownies! DAF