Tuesday, December 19, 2006


Why Is Genarlow Wilson in Prison?
After a wild New Year’s Eve party, six Douglasville teens found themselves charged with child molestation under a legal technicality. The boy who refused to take a plea now faces a decade behind bars.By CHANDRA R. THOMAS
Around 3 a.m., Michelle awoke from a drunken daze. She was lying on the floor between two double beds and wearing nothing but socks. In a panic, she called her mother from a cell phone, asking—no, pleading—for her to come now. Michelle managed to find her overnight bag and scrounged up a shirt and underwear to wear outside. Her mother picked her up in front of the hotel. Once they got in the car, Michelle’s mother told her daughter that she reeked of liquor and marijuana and as soon as they got home she needed to take a bath. Michelle got into the tub, but then broke down and told her upset mom, “I think they raped me.” She dressed, and mother and daughter headed to the Douglasville Police Department. After they filed a report, investigators ordered Michelle to go to a hospital for an examination. Later that morning, loud knocks at the doors of rooms 135 and 136 awakened the stragglers still there. Officers announced that they were there to investigate a gang rape that had been reported by Michelle. The youngsters sat around bleary-eyed as detectives questioned them; meantime, after securing a search warrant, officers scoured the rooms for evidence, carefully collecting almost a dozen used condoms and wrappers that were found strewn about the floor and in wastebaskets. Just as they were wrapping up their search, detective Ed Reece, a crime scene technician, noticed something in the corner of the room: the video camera. Over the next few days, investigators interviewed about 14 teens who had been at the party. Eventually five young men admitted to detectives that they had engaged in sexual intercourse with Michelle and that Tracy had performed oral sex on them. Officers continued tracking down evidence. After the Christmas holiday break, on the first day of the second semester of his long-awaited senior year, Genarlow Wilson’s charmed life came to a screeching halt. The football player and track star, homecoming king and honor-roll student was met by sheriff’s deputies in his Douglas County High classroom. Genarlow and his friend Narada Williams, who had also attended the now-notorious party, were marched in handcuffs through the same hallways that had been filled with happy memories. It all seemed surreal, but it didn’t take long for Genarlow to realize that this was no dream. Along with Genarlow and Narada, Ryan Barnwell, Cortez Robinson, Adrien Willis and Frankie Henry—all 17 years old—were arrested on a host of charges including rape, contributing to the delinquency of a minor, aggravated sodomy and aggravated child molestation. As lawyers and detectives met with the boys and their families, the impact of the charges began to sink in. Clearly, rape is illegal in all American states, but in Georgia, sex, including oral sex, with anyone under the age of 16 can be classified as aggravated child molestation—even if it occurs between two teens less than three years apart in age, as in the instance of 17-year-old Genarlow and 15-year-old Tracy. In fact, under Georgia law, the penalty is actually more severe for a person found guilty of engaging in oral sex with a minor than for having intercourse (which is classified as misdemeanor statutory rape), even if the perpetrator is just a few years older than the minor. The intricacies of the Georgia law made national news nearly two years ago when aggravated child molestation charges almost sent 18-year-old Marcus Dixon from Rome, Georgia, to prison for a decade. Dixon, a former Pepperell High School football star, who is black, was accused of raping a white classmate who was three months shy of her 16th birthday. When that case broke, even the author of the statute, state Representative Tyrone Brooks, argued that the law was intended to protect children from adult sexual predators, not to police teenage sex. According to Douglas County District Attorney David McDade, most of the six young men charged in the Douglasville case had been in trouble with the law before, including one now facing similar charges nearly two years after this case. Still, none of them or their families had the faintest notion that their actions that New Year’s Eve night would haunt them for the rest of their lives. Initially the young men—dubbed the Douglasville Six by local media—stood united. Their parents hired attorneys, and all of the boys vehemently maintained their innocence. But as the reality of the charges stacked against them began to sink in, the pressure began to mount. Four of the teens buckled and signed documents—some without even their parents’ knowledge—accepting pleas to lesser charges in exchange for lighter prison terms. The pleas varied, but there were some commonalities: None would serve the mandatory 10 years in prison for aggravated child molestation (for having oral sex with 15-year-old Tracy), but all would be registered sex offenders forever. Cheryl Arnold, Ryan Barnwell’s aunt, says prosecutors used scare tactics to pressure the kids into accepting plea deals. “He was scared, they made him think that they would get 30 years in prison if they went to trial,” Arnold says of her nephew, who is now at Lee State Prison in Leesburg, Georgia. “He had never even lived away from home before and now he’s in prison. It’s just horrible.” So the six became two. Genarlow, the only teen with no prior run-ins with the law, and Frankie decided to stand trial and fight the charges. Surely, they and their families believed, jurors would see that this was just a case of teenagers being teenagers. There was no ill will, no malice, no intent to commit a crime. After all, Michelle had arrived at the party tipsy; she’d been drinking Hennessy cognac that afternoon even before the party began. She voluntarily continued to drink and smoke with them. She had packed a bag, obviously with the intention of spending the night. She had also reportedly flirted relentlessly with the guys, including her old high school track buddy Genarlow. And more importantly, even Michelle’s own girlfriend, Natasha*, who’d also been at the party, told investigators that she had never heard Michelle say “no” to the guys. As for Tracy, she did not drink or smoke that night, but willingly performed oral sex on several of the guys, practically one after the other, as the telltale videotape showed. Tracy had not wanted to press charges and was as surprised as the boys that police showed up at the hotel that New Year’s morning. At no point did anyone at the party discuss their ages. They were all peers. But the morning the trial was to begin, Genarlow learned that his lone ally, Frankie, had also opted to take a plea. Genarlow would have to stand alone in this battle. With the support of his mother, Juannessa Bennett, and his trial attorney, Michael Mann, he embarked upon quite literally the fight for his life. The trial began the morning of February 21, 2005, at the Douglas County Courthouse, with the words “justice” boldly etched onto the front of the grand stone-and-brick structure. The courtroom was packed daily with members of the community eagerly awaiting the salacious testimony. Genarlow sat at a table with his attorney at his side. Each day his mother arrived alone and sat in the area reserved for the public, without a family member or friend there to lend support. Genarlow was scared, trembling at times, but he held on to the conviction that no fair-minded juror could look at that videotape, hear the testimony of others who attended that party and, in good conscience, call him a child molester. He would have seemed to be a model defendant. Attractive, popular and outgoing, Genarlow had been headed for a bright future. He had a 3.2 grade point average and athletic abilities that kept college coaches calling to offer football and track scholarships. He was All Conference in football both his junior and senior years. He was voted 11th-grade prom prince and his senior year was capped off with a distinguished honor: He was elected Douglas County High’s first-ever homecoming king. Normally extroverted and upbeat, Genarlow was sedate and still as he listened to Michelle, the mothers of both girls, his friends and friends of the alleged victims testify at the five-day trial that played out with the intensity of a television drama. The melodrama heightened with each screening of the by-now-infamous videotape. Labeled “state’s exhibit seven,” it was dubbed onto a Maxell VHS tape bearing the words “for everyday recording” and “frequent re-recording” on the cover. Parts of the tape were played so often that, at one point, even the judge requested that it be shown again only if absolutely necessary. The testimony was explicit and questioning intense, with testy exchanges between Genarlow and prosecutor Eddie Barker. Throughout the trial Genarlow was hammered with specific—and often graphic—queries about the night’s encounters, sometimes exasperating the teen: Genarlow: . . . I’m pretty sure when you and your wife engage in sexual activity, you do stuff . . . you probably don’t want to discuss . . . Barker: That’s because my wife is over 16, Mr. Wilson. At one point, defense attorney Michael Mann elaborated on Genarlow’s point in an attempt to demonstrate the absurdity of policing teen sex: Mann: Have you ever fooled around with some girl who’s about your age and asked to see her ID before you had sex? Genarlow: No. I mean, it’s people who go to the same school . . . Mann: You didn’t ask to see her date of birth or month or hour of birth before she gave this blow job? Genarlow: No, sir. Observers said no moments were more dramatic than when the young defendant pleaded in his own defense: Genarlow: . . . Aggravated child molestation is when like a 60-year—some old man like messing with 10-year-old girls. I’m 17, the girl was 15, sir. You call that child molestation, two years apart? Barker: I didn’t write the law. Genarlow: I didn’t write the law, either. Barker: That’s what the law states is aggravated child molestation, Mr. Wilson, not me. Genarlow: Well, sir, I understand you’re just doing your job. I don’t blame you. . . . But do you think it’s fair? . . . Would you want your son on trial for something like this? But the courtroom showdowns were no match for the fallout that followed the reading of the verdict. Genarlow’s mother, who had been awaiting word from home, raced into the courtroom with her young daughter in tow just in time for the announcement. It was standing room only, with people even lining the walls, as jury forewoman Marie Manigault stood up in the jury stand and read, “We, the jury, find the defendant, Genarlow Raevion Wilson, not guilty of rape. . . . We, the jury, find the defendant, Genarlow Raevion Wilson, guilty of aggravated child molestation this 25th day of February 2005.” The room erupted into a collective gasp and Genarlow, dressed in a plaid button-down and khakis, sunk his face into his hands and began sobbing uncontrollably. His mother clutched her young daughter and cried as two armed guards handcuffed her son and led him out of the courtroom. The jury filed into the back room where they had deliberated for about five hours earlier that day. It was not until then, says Manigault, that attorney Michael Mann told them that their verdict meant a mandatory 10-year sentence for Genarlow. The room exploded. “People were screaming, crying, beating against the walls,” she recalls. “I just went limp. They had to help me to a chair.” Manigault says she feels that prosecutors gave the jury instructions that left them no choice but to convict Genarlow on the aggravated child molestation charge. She says that she and her fellow jurors believed that their verdict had to be unanimous. She says that other options—such as a hung jury—were not thoroughly explained to them. “It all boils down to the fact that there’s the letter of the law and there’s the spirit of the law,” says Manigault, who claims that she still struggles to make peace with her role in the case and that she could not sleep for months after the verdict. “Under the letter of the law these young men were guilty, but under the spirit of the law they were not guilty,” she says. “Because we were ignorant we sent this child to jail.” It looks like a church revival is going on. People of all ages—from arm babies to gray-haired grandmothers—pack the long dark pews at St. James A.M.E. Church. Wooden ceiling fans spin slowly overhead. The television photographers huddled in the aisles and the many microphones that crowd the podium in the pulpit are a dead giveaway that there’s much more to this gathering. Speakers, including state Representative Roger Bruce, state Senator Vincent Fort, former Atlanta city councilman Derrick Boazman and state Representative Mabel Thomas take turns addressing the crowd at a rally held to increase awareness about the Douglasville Six case and to raise money for Genarlow’s defense fund. The parents and relatives of the six young men are sprinkled about the room; some hold photographs of their sons. In a side pew, Genarlow’s mother cuddles with her young daughter; both are dressed in the same vibrant fuchsia. Marcus Dixon’s mother, Peri Jones, sits nearby in a peach suit, the same one she wore the day her son was released from prison. At one point, the two mothers address the crowd, tearfully holding hands side-by-side. Other speakers, including Cortez Robinson’s father, Lynn Lindley, elicit amens and thunderous applause. “This law was meant to protect our children and now it’s got our children,” says Lindley, alongside his wife, Lisa. The gathering ends with a call for support and a pass of the collection plate. The outcry sparks a sense of déjà vu on the heels of the notorious Dixon case, which caught national media attention when it was featured on The Oprah Winfrey Show and Real Sports With Bryant Gumbel. Jurors acquitted Dixon of rape, aggravated assault, false imprisonment and sexual battery, but he was sentenced to 10 years for aggravated child molestation. His lawyers appealed to the Georgia Supreme Court, which overturned the aggravated child molestation charge and charged him only with statutory rape, a misdemeanor, reducing his sentence to the 15 months served. The court did not overturn the controversial state law, but did make a commentary for clarification, noting that in the court’s opinion, the intent of the Georgia General Assembly in drafting the law was to punish Dixon’s conduct as misdemeanor statutory rape rather than felony aggravated child molestation. The court also indicated that “Georgia’s statutory rape and child molestation statutes must be considered together to determine legislative intent.” Marcus Dixon’s attorney, David Balser, has noted that the main difference in the two cases is that Genarlow’s involves oral sex, which is classified as aggravated child molestation under Georgia law, while Dixon’s case involved sexual intercourse, which can actually carry lesser charges. David McDade, a Douglas County native who has helped his hometown earn a reputation for being tough on crime, spent 10 years as a prosecutor before he was elected district attorney in 1990. He’s a personable man with an unassuming demeanor. Nothing about his thinning gray hair, bushy moustache, cerise complexion, baby blue button-down and brick-red tie lends to the menacing reputation his critics describe. He’s a husband and a father of three. His desk, in an office tucked in a corner of the Douglas County Courthouse, is crowded with framed family photos; his wall hangings reveal an affinity for the Georgia Bulldogs. He’s unapologetic about his reputation for being tough on crime. Nobody ever said that going after criminals would be easy. His job is to think about the victims. It’s something he does proudly. In fact, he previously served on the Prosecuting Attorneys’ Council of Georgia board and currently chairs the Legislative Affairs Committee for the District Attorneys’ Association of Georgia. In 2005, McDade was named D.A. of the year by the D.A. Association of Georgia. The same year, the Criminal Justice Coordinating Council presented him with the Eagle Award for outstanding contributions in the field of victim services. McDade says that he agrees that consensual teenage sex, including oral sex, does not necessarily warrant a decade-long prison sentence, but he insists there were no other options to consider in this case as long as that law remains on the books. He shrugs off his critics’ assertions that he could have dropped the aggravated child molestation charges, insisting that there was no way for him to turn a blind eye to a crime that was clearly documented on videotape. “We don’t believe that a 10-year sentence is an appropriate punishment [in this case], but he made that decision to put himself in that predicament,” explains McDade, of Genarlow’s refusal to cop a plea. “He has decided to become a martyr because people have been whispering in his ear, ‘We’ll make you famous like Marcus Dixon.’” The Douglasville Six case, McDade insists, in no way detracts from his long-standing track record. McDade says that critics are merely playing the proverbial race card. “I think there is an attempt to shy away from a focus on the specifics of this case by some who would like to use any case to create racial disharmony in this community,” he says. “I think the members of the black community should stand up and say, ‘We don’t condone the behavior of these young men.’” Had he not pursued charges against the boys, his critics could have just as easily chastised him for failing to protect the rights of the two black females. “I’m standing up for African-American victims in this case, as I would for any white victim,” says McDade, an alum of Douglas County High, where he played baseball. “Calling me a racist denigrates the people who are victims in this case.” Both McDade and prosecutor Eddie Barker shrug off what they call “hype” spawned by the case. “The media has painted these young men as choir boys, sweet and innocent, but that is not the case. The truth is in here,” McDade states matter-of-factly, pointing to a folder full of papers listing some of the defendants’ previous arrests. Superior Court Judge David Emerson decided to deny First Offender status to all of the six young men—a distinction that could have automatically lightened their sentences and removed the offenses from their records after they completed probation—because five of the six young men involved in the case had criminal records. McDade says it is “office policy” that no one convicted of child molestation should benefit from First Offender status. According to McDade, prior to this incident Frankie Henry had 29 arrests in Douglas County on charges including aggravated assault, criminal trespassing and shoplifting. In fact, as recently as October 2005, he was charged with child molestation and statutory rape for allegedly impregnating a 12-year-old Douglas County girl he was accused of having sex with while the Douglasville Six cases were pending. McDade says DNA testing conducted on the baby and the victim confirmed that Frankie is the father. He reportedly told investigators he had sex with the girl but did not know her age at the time. Narada Williams, who brought the video camera to the party, had at least four prior arrests—three as a juvenile and one as an adult. Cortez Robinson, who rented one of the hotel rooms, had 12 priors, including simple battery, burglary, criminal trespassing and possession of alcohol as a minor. Ryan Barnwell, who rented the other room, had a 1998 arrest for battery in Bibb County. Adrien had at least one previous arrest in Cobb County. McDade says he further supported the judge’s decision to treat Genarlow—the only one who had not had any run-ins with the law prior to this case—the same as the other boys because he does not believe in offering First Offender status in sex crime cases. McDade’s tough stance on sex crimes seems reasonable, noble even, until a closer look is taken at several recent cases in Douglas County, including one indirectly involving McDade’s own teenage son. At the time that Genarlow’s trial was underway, just down the hall in the same courthouse, Douglas County Judge Robert James Baker was hearing the case of Alexander High School English teacher and cheering coach Kari McCarley. The 27-year-old was found guilty of having a sexual relationship with a 17-year-old male student who attended the school where she worked. She was sentenced to three years probation and 90 days in jail. McDade says he recused himself from that case because his then 17-year-old son, a student at Alexander High, had been interviewed by investigators about the case. The boy had told investigators that McCarley had called his cell phone nearly 30 times. McDade says his son was never romantically involved with McCarley. “I was pissed off as hell about the outcome, but [because the victim was 17] the maximum sentence she could have received by law was three years,” explains McDade. “We suggested prison time, but the judge imposed a sentence that he felt was right. She [McCarley] was not having sex with a student directly under her supervision.” But there are also other cases of adults—white adults—prosecuted by the Douglas County District Attorney’s office for sex crimes involving minors and received far lighter sentences than any of the teens in the Douglasville Six case. Case in point: Jack Stewart, a 24-year-old volunteer coach at Heirway Christian Academy in Douglas County, who received 30 days in jail and 10 years probation for fondling the 15-year-old daughter of a couple whose house he was living at temporarily. McDade notes that he objected in court to the “inappropriately light” sentence. In the case of 26-year-old George Tsimpides, First Offender status was extended in a sex crime. Tsimpides received 20 days in jail after he pleaded guilty to luring a 15-year-old girl he’d met on the Internet to Arbor Place Mall with the intention of engaging in sex with her. McDade says he publicly objected to that sentence. The D.A. himself has not been immune to sexual misconduct charges. In 1995, two female employees who worked in his office claimed McDade sexually harassed them, creating a “hostile work environment.” The charges were later dismissed. McDade insists they are irrelevant. “According to the summary judgment, I won completely and they lost completely,” he says. These cases, according to the Douglas County chapter of the NAACP, point to a pattern of discrimination. The civil rights organization, which has led rallies in support of the Douglasville Six, contends that if the young men involved were white the charges would have been dismissed. “The D.A.’s office is caught up in that good ol’ boy syndrome, misapplying a law that was never meant for teenagers,” says chapter president Kimberly Alexander. Statistics provided by the Campaign for Juvenile Justice, a nonprofit advocacy group based in Atlanta, suggest that Alexander’s assertions may not be far off the mark, particularly when it comes to trying teens as adults. According to the organization’s analysis of Justice Department statistics, African-American and Latino youth are 45 percent of Georgia’s youth population, but comprise 77 percent of the youth arrested under SB 440, a controversial measure that was passed by the Georgia General Assembly in 1994. SB 440 gives superior courts the power to charge children aged 13–17 as adults for committing the so called “seven deadly sins”: murder, voluntary manslaughter, rape, aggravated sodomy, aggravated child molestation, aggravated sexual battery, and armed robbery if committed with a firearm. Furthermore, the organization also found that 46 percent of criminal cases involving white youth were transferred back to juvenile court versus 25 percent of cases involving African-American youth. Such statistics inspired Cathryn Ferrigno last year to create a nonprofit agency that aims to work with the juvenile courts in Georgia to create alternatives to incarceration for youths arrested for crimes. The CROPS (Community Responsibility Opens Possibility and Sustainability) program will work with the courts before youth are sentenced. “Research has shown that when kids go to prison a first time, they tend to go back,” Ferrigno says. “Kids need to be given the opportunity, with the right support, to prove to themselves and the court that they’re capable of being productive citizens.” Instead of exclusively pointing fingers at district attorneys’ offices, Ferrigno and many other observers argue that the crux of the Douglasville Six case is rooted in shortcomings within the state legislature. “These mandatory minimums strip judges of the opportunity to exercise discretion and to take into account the specifics of a case,” Ferrigno says. “On the legislative level they’re scared to touch sentencing issues, afraid that it’ll appear like they’re not being tough on crime.” Prosecutor Eddie Barker, a father of three, admits that he worries about his own children getting trapped by the law, but echoes a similar sentiment to McDade. “I don’t doubt for a second that Genarlow had any idea that what he was doing that night would get him 10 years in prison, but ignorance is not an excuse for breaking the law. When he says he’s not a child molester, what he is saying is that he is not a traditional child molester, but the way the law is written he is a child molester. We can’t change the law; that’s up to the folks [legislators] in Atlanta.” Some observers, including Genarlow’s own appeals attorney, B.J. Bernstein, dismiss any suggestion that this case is about race. “Just as many white kids are caught up in this law as black kids,” says Bernstein, who worked on the defense side of other high-profile cases including The Gold Club and the State of Georgia v. Powell case, which declared Georgia’s law forbidding sodomy between two consenting adults unconstitutional. Political pundits like Vincent Fort disagree. “Some whites and Jews were victims of lynchings in the old South, but that does not negate the fact that the overwhelming majority of those lynched were black. Just because something also happens to a white person does not necessarily mean that it is not racially motivated,” he argues. Fort, who continues to raise money for Genarlow’s defense fund, insists that race and class are inextricably tied to the heart of the matter. “If these six young men were not African-American, they would not be facing these kind of sentences. The fact of the matter is that if what they did is a crime, millions of teenagers are committing crimes every day.” Fort’s sentiments are echoed by civil rights activist Jesse Jackson, who calls the case a “throwback to the lynching period” in America. “Clearly the time and the crime do not correspond,” says Jackson, founder and president of the Rainbow/PUSH Coalition, during a visit to Atlanta. “Yet another example of excessive sentencing for black and brown youth. The prison system is quick to profile them, arrest them and process them.” In August 2005, Judge Emerson denied Bernstein’s request for a new trial. At press time, Bernstein said that the Georgia Court of Appeals was tentatively scheduled to hear oral arguments in the case in March 2006. Bernstein hopes Genarlow’s case will ultimately serve as a precedent for the state law to be modified. “We need to change this law so that young people who don’t have a violent bone in their body—just testosterone—aren’t punished in the same way as people who really need to be on that sex offenders’ registry,” says Bernstein, who handles many sex crime cases. “There are plenty of people, here in Georgia, who are being convicted of child molestation and getting far less than 10 years in prison.” Genarlow’s story has garnered some national media attention, but nothing near the level of the Dixon case. Bernstein and Genarlow’s mother were interviewed about the case last year on Court TV and Fox’s The O’Reilly Factor. Locally, the case drew plenty of reaction on the African-American-targeted news and talk radio station WAOK 1380 AM, but most local media outlets have either ignored the case completely or only covered some of the rallies and vigils held after Genarlow’s guilty verdict. While the story was covered in the Douglasville papers, at press time, it had not been picked up by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. A Lexis-Nexis search (the primary resource for legal and news research) for the period January 2003 through October 2005 turned up more than 2,000 mentions of the Dixon case and fewer than half a dozen on Wilson. While the story hasn’t been as high-profile in broadcast and print media as Dixon’s, it has created a stir in some Internet chat rooms, with people across the country and as far away as Canada and the United Kingdom sharing their perspectives. While total strangers engage in spirited debates about the merits of the case on the Web and elsewhere, the harsh reality continues to sink in each day for many people directly and indirectly involved in the case, particularly Genarlow’s mother. A single mother of two, Juannessa Bennett is a typical mom. She wears her hair in a ponytail, cooks dinner and picks her young daughter up from Montessori school. She convincingly maintains a strong front, but the adversity she’s experienced in this ordeal invades her youthful face, the same coppery color as her son’s. What’s happened to Genarlow and his friends is far from anything she ever imagined. “Their whole lives are ruined,” she says, in between bites of a garden salad at a Caribbean restaurant in Douglasville. It’s just past lunchtime, but only a few diners remain. One seems to recognize her from a distance and discreetly points her out to his companion. Bennett, now all too familiar with being recognized in this small community, is oblivious to what’s happening and continues talking. “I’m just praying for the day he’ll be out and able to go school,” she says, tears welling in her eyes. Genarlow’s 7-year-old baby sister, Jiaya, a shy girl with wide eyes and pigtails, is oblivious to the unsavory details of her brother’s case, but she seems to share her mother’s sorrow. “All she knows is her brother is in trouble and she misses him,” explains Bennett. “They were very close. He loves his little sister.” Bennett says that throughout this ordeal, this living nightmare, she has lost and regained about 20 pounds and endured many sleepless nights. She can sleep now, but only after Genarlow’s daily calls from jail. The staff at the Douglas County jail knows Bennett well. They should. She sees them twice a week. She hands over her ID and signs the visitors’ log before she’s buzzed into the restricted visitors’ area. The sound of whining children bounces off the long wooden benches propped in the center of the modest room packed with many others. Her face lights up as Genarlow emerges in the small booth and takes a seat. A tiny glass window trimmed in dusky brown wood frames his youthful face. He’s wearing a tan prison jumpsuit; the sleeves of his cream-colored thermal undershirt cover his coppery arms, exposing only his hands. The hairs of his slight moustache encircle his full lips; the edges of shiny gold eyeglasses peek out of his left shirt pocket. “I just could not live with myself having that label [of child molester] for the rest of my life,” Genarlow says, beaming at the sight of his mother. “Even after serving time in prison I would have to register as a sex offender wherever I lived and if I applied for a job for the rest of my life, all for participating in a consensual sex act with a girl just two years younger than me,” he says, his voice trailing off. “It’s a lifelong sentence in itself. I AM NOT A CHILD MOLESTER!” His voice, deep yet still youthful, is slightly muffled by the crackling sound that emanates from the black telephone that he uses to talk to visitors. The antiquated looking device, with the tangled silver cord, is now his only means of communicating with the outside world. In this conversation, his first interview with a reporter, he speaks with a calmness that belies his predicament. His words are optimistic, hopeful even, but there’s an underlying sadness tinged with impatience that lingers in his voice. “What if I had kids one day,” he asks aloud, his intensity drowning out the buzz of the many other conversations underway in the crowded visitors’ room. “I could not even live near their school. If I had accepted that deal, after I got out of prison I still would not have been able to live in my mom’s house with my little sister.” He says he’s remorseful about the poor choices he and his friends made at that party two years ago, but he’s adamant about two points: He did not rape anyone and he had no idea that allowing a girl just two years younger to perform oral sex on him was against the law. Genarlow had planned to attend the Georgia Military College in Milledgeville or possibly one of the three other schools that had made offers, but now, instead of a college dormitory filled with young freshmen, the long days that spill into even longer nights are mostly spent reading books—including novels from Oprah’s Book Club—in a jail dormitory in Douglas County filled with accused criminals. His promising future, Genarlow contends, was snatched away by a racist judicial system and an overzealous district attorney trying to make an example of him and his friends. “I’m hoping for the best, but expecting the worst,” he says candidly. “I hope to get out of here so that I can be a mentor or a counselor to kids and help raise awareness about this law and tell them what I’ve been through. I wish this would all be over.” Well aware of his place at the center of an ever-brewing controversy, Genarlow says he’s bracing himself for two possible outcomes—spending the next nine years behind bars or being rescued by the courts. He’s optimistic. “One day I want to have kids of my own,” he says. “I’ll tell them what happened and I hope that they’re proud that I made it out. I’ll just look at it as something I had to go through.” He keeps on speaking even as a guard taps him on the shoulder. “I’m sorry. I’ve got to go,” he says, rising from his chair with the telephone receiver still perched on his ear. He glances back and blows a kiss to his mom, then disappears around a corner. For updates on the case, visit wilsonappeal.com.

Copyright 2006 Atlanta MagazineAnother production by Media Firma

Saturday, December 16, 2006


Mr. Hitler, Do You Have the Time?
The despicable U-Boat watch.
By Richard CohenPosted Friday, Dec. 15, 2006, at 6:15 PM ET
I confess to being in the market for an expensive watch. I say I confess because I know the watch I buy for a lot of money will not be more accurate than a watch I could have bought for a lot less, but there you have it. This explains why I gave more than cursory attention to a double-page ad in the Sunday New York Times for expensive watches. One caught my eye. It seemed oversized, which is the fashion these days, and built to take a bullet or two, which is required these days, and undoubtedly water resistant down to where the homicidal stingrays roam, and it was altogether handsome, although not for me. But it was the name that caught my eye: U-Boat.
U-Boat? The Unterseeboot responsible for sinking untold allied ships during World War II, costing many lives and so impressing Winston Churchill that he said, "The only thing that really frightened me during the war was the U-boat peril"? That U-boat? Yes, apparently. And that raises another question: Who would buy, not to mention wear, a watch named after a killer sub that, while used in World War I, really earned its rep in World War II as a fighter on the side of the Nazis? In other words, who could be so ahistorical, ignorant, or just plain tasteless to wear something on their wrist that immediately brings to mind, among other things, the ovens of Auschwitz?
One answer is that it has to be the same people who will soon bid on the car CNNMoney.com and AOL both called "Hitler race car." This Auto Union D-Type is expected to go for as much as $12 million at a Paris auction. The car was built by Ferdinand Porsche, then with Auto Union, the company now known as Audi. In the '30s, Porsche accepted Hitler's challenge to build a car that would showcase German technological advances. This 485-horsepower little buggy was the result. It could do a cool 185 miles per hour, but it cannot, at least for me, outrun its unsavory genesis.
I suppose that whoever buys the car can say that Hitler never actually owned it or used it or, maybe, even saw it. It ought to be no more odious than your run-of-the-mill Volkswagen, which was also produced (by the ubiquitous F. Porsche) at the suggestion of the late Führer, or the Mercedes-Benz open touring car, the one often seen in pictures of Nazi rallies—Hitler standing, offering the stiff-armed Nazi salute. Still, the fact that the D-Type has been called "Hitler's race car" is enough for me. I could not slip into the car without thinking of how it came about.
You might think I am particularly sensitive to such matters since I am a Cohen of a certain age and therefore unable to look on the bright side of Nazism. Maybe so. I love my Wagner, but I cannot listen without also envisioning the guests at Hitler's mountain home, the Berghof, forced to listen to the Führer's beloved "Ring Cycle" yet again. Yet, I have owned VWs, BMWs, and Mercedes in my time, in addition to coffee makers made by an assortment of German firms once opportunistically diversified into the genocide biz. What bothers me, I suppose, is a more immediate connection with evil—the name of Hitler attached to the car, either because he used it or he sought its creation. In the case of the U-Boat watch, the manufacturer's Web page says it was originally commissioned by the Italian military but was not made until way after the war. Be that as it may, no one sees the term U-boat and thinks of Napoli.
I once bought a KKK robe at a junk shop in southern Pennsylvania. I considered it historic and well worth the price, something like $1.50. I took it home to Washington, unsure of what to do with it until, that night, it occurred to me I had a problem on my hands: the maid. The woman—a black woman, as if you didn't know—was due the next day and might come across my piece of history. She might not consider it quite as historic as I did. She might even be sickened by it and wonder—could it be?—if the rancid thing was actually, in a membership sort of way, mine. I stuffed the robe in the back of my sweater drawer where it remained, glowing and pulsing in my active imagination, until I gave it to a friend. Like me, he considered the robe to be a historic artifact and, like me, he soon suffered from a suffocating queasiness, the sense the robe was taking over the house. He wound up burning the thing in the backyard, lest D.C.'s sanitation workers discover it in the trash.
So, I can understand that one man's historical artifact is another man's sheer horror. Still, I wonder how anyone could stand having an Andy Warhol silk screen of Mao Zedong on the wall. Warhol executed it back in 1971 to 1972 and it goes for a pretty penny nowadays—$17.4 million, at Christie's just this year. Warhol was a political dunce and probably when he did his Mao screen, he was unaware that the man was not merely Mother Jones in drag, but a genuine ogre who was personally responsible for the deaths of millions—with millions more to come in the nearly incomprehensible Cultural Revolution. Beyond that, and just for the record, he was a slob—unwashed, unkempt, and a serial deflowerer of smilingly reluctant young girls. There is no way I can look at Warhol's Mao and not think of these things and wonder if any of the people who own one are familiar with Mao's history. Would they own a Warhol Hitler print, if he had done one? How about an early Pol Pot, in profile, of course?
Clearly, I am some sort of fuddy-duddy. The U-Boat watch, created by Italo Fontana, apparently sells well enough for it to go for almost $3,000. But, just as clearly, the name resonates with the people who buy the watch—otherwise, why not call it the Nautilus or the Calypso Sun? That is the part that bothers me—they accept the watch on the same amoral terms as those who ran the U-boats themselves—self-described brave men working at the tough business of war and not, in their own turtle-necked-Das Boot way, complicit in the deaths of millions. The people who buy a U-Boat are a special sort. They can spend thousands on a watch but, fundamentally, they cannot tell you the time of day.Richard Cohen is a columnist for the Washington

Monday, November 27, 2006

Not bad for melodrama
National Catholic Reporter
A year ago we lamented in this space the disappearance of the U.S. Catholic bishops. Well, we meant that in a metaphorical sense. They hadn’t actually disappeared; they had just become far less visible on the national scene than in an earlier era.
Here’s how we put it: “We are watching the disintegration of a once-great national church, the largest denomination in the United States, into regional groupings bent on avoiding the spotlight and the big issues.”
We noted that there was war and starvation everywhere; fresh clergy sex abuse reports out of Philadelphia, Los Angeles, and Spokane, Wash., to name a few; 20 percent of U.S. parishes without a pastor; a Congress poised to reduce health care coverage and food stamps; the United States accused of torture and keeping combatants in secret prisons; and so on. And the bishops had nothing to say. They would talk only to each other about internal church matters.
We are compelled, then, to report that the bishops have not entirely disappeared. For they gathered again, in Baltimore this year, and, continuing their trip inward, issued documents on such burning issues as birth control, ministry to persons with “a homosexual inclination,” and how to prepare to receive Communion. Now, none of these matters is unimportant. Don’t get the wrong impression. We’ve had documents aplenty about all of them before. And these topics -- unlike the war in Iraq, say, or what it means to have a president and vice president endorsing torture -- are even covered in the Catechism of the Catholic Church.
So why again? Apparently the bishops feel that people just aren’t listening. If that’s their hunch, we’d agree. Why aren’t they listening? Let’s consider for starters the document on contraception. A lot of the U.S. bishops today might say there are a lot of bad, or at least ignorant, Catholics out there, Catholics influenced by the contraceptive culture, for instance, who no longer know good from evil.
Maybe they’re right. More likely, though, it’s because the teaching makes little sense, doesn’t match the experience of lay Catholics and tends to reduce all of human love to the act of breeding.
In short, the bishops aren’t terribly persuasive or clear when they talk about sex, and they tend to want to talk about sex a lot. To be sure, they say lots of lovely and lofty things about marital love, about how it completes people and cooperates with God’s plan and fills married lives with joy and happiness. You can want not to have children, say the bishops, you just can’t do anything “unnatural” about it. It’s a strange concept, like not wanting to die of heart disease while not doing anything “unnatural” about it.
They make the point that if every time a married couple makes love they are not open to having children, then they’re not giving “all” of themselves to each other. If you use birth control, say the bishops, and every single act is not open to having children, then “being responsible about sex simply means limiting its consequences -- avoiding disease and using contraceptives to prevent pregnancy.” Whew! So that’s it, eh?
It’s either be open to having kids or married sex is no more significant than an encounter with a prostitute. Such a view of marriage and sexuality and sexual intimacy can only have been written by people straining mightily to fit the mysteries, fullness and candidly human pleasure of sex into a schema that violently divides the human person into unrecognizable parts. There’s a reason 96 percent of Catholics have ignored the birth control teaching for decades. We doubt the new document will significantly change that percentage.
So it is with gays. Here again, church authorities try to fit together two wildly diverging themes. They go something like this: Homosexuals are “objectively disordered” (that’s about as bad as it humanly gets, in our understanding of things), but we love them and want them to be members of our community.
Only this time out, the bishops are not using the term homosexual “orientation” (a definite position) but homosexual “inclination” (a liking for something or a tendency toward). Sly, no? The inference to be drawn, we presume, is that someone inclined one way can just incline another way, whereas someone with an orientation is pretty much stuck there.
That science and human experience generally say otherwise is of little concern, apparently, though the bishops were clear they weren’t suggesting that homosexuals are required to change. This time, too, the bishops, while acknowledging that those with homosexual tendencies should seek supportive friendships, advise homosexuals to be quiet about their inclinations in church. “For some persons, revealing their homosexual tendencies to certain close friends, family members, a spiritual director, confessor, or members of a church support group may provide some spiritual and emotional help and aid them in their growth in Christian life. In the context of parish life, however, general public self-disclosures are not helpful and should not be encouraged.”
The next paragraph in the document, by the way, begins, “Sad to say, there are many persons with a homosexual inclination who feel alienated from the church.” You can’t make this stuff up.
It is difficult to figure out how to approach these documents. They are products of some realm so removed from the real lives of the faithful one has to wonder why any group of busy men administering a church would bother. They ignore science, human experience and the groups they attempt to characterize. The documents are not only embarrassing but insulting and degrading to those the bishops are charged to lead. The saddest thing is that the valuable insights the bishops have into the deficiencies and influences of the wider culture get buried.
Where is this all going?
No one’s come out with a program, but we’ll venture yet one more hunch. It has become apparent in recent years that there’s been an upsurge in historical ecclesiastical finery and other goods. We’ve seen more birettas (those funny three-peak hats with the fuzzy ball on top that come in different colors depending on clerical rank) and cassocks (the kind with real buttons, no zippers for the purists) and ecclesiastically correct color shoes and socks, lots of lacy surplices and even the capa magna (yards and yards of silk, a cape long enough that it has to be attended by two altar boys or seminarians, also in full regalia). In some places they’re even naming monsignors again.
It’s as if someone has discovered a props closet full of old stuff and they’re putting it out all over the stage. Bishops, pestered by the abuse scandal that they’ve avoided looking full in the face, find it easier to try to order others’ lives. They have found the things of a more settled time, a time when their authority wasn’t dependent on persuading or relating to other humans. It was enough to have the office and the clothing. Things worked. Dig a little deeper in the closet and bring out the Latin texts, bring back the old documents, bring back the days when homosexuals were quiet and told no one about who they essentially are. Someone even found a canopy under which the royally clad leader can process.
Now that’s order.
Now that’s the church.
Bring up the lights a little higher so all can see.
Before it all fades to irrelevance.
National Catholic Reporter, November 24, 2006
50 Shots Fired, and the Experts Offer a Theory
Experts suggested that "contagious shooting" played a role in the police shooting of a bridegroom in Queens.
It is known in police parlance as "contagious shooting" - gunfire that spreads among officers who believe that they, or their colleagues, are facing a threat. It spreads like germs, like laughter, or fear. An officer fires, so his colleagues do, too.
The phenomenon appears to have happened last year, when eight officers fired 43 shots at an armed man in Queens, killing him. In July, three officers fired 26 shots at a pit bull that had bitten a chunk out of an officer's leg in a Bronx apartment building. And there have been other episodes: in 1995, in the Bronx, officers fired 125 bullets during a bodega robbery, with one officer firing 45 rounds.
Just what happened on Saturday is still being investigated. Police experts, however, suggested in interviews yesterday that contagious shooting played a role in a fatal police shooting in Queens Saturday morning. According to the police account, five officers fired 50 shots at a bridegroom who, leaving his bachelor party at a strip club, twice drove his car into a minivan carrying plainclothes police officers investigating the club.
The bridegroom, Sean Bell, who was to be married hours later, was killed, and two of his friends were wounded, one critically.
To the layman, and to the loved ones of those who were shot, 50 shots seems a startlingly high number, especially since the men were found to be unarmed. And police experts concede that the number was high. Yet they also note that in those chaotic and frightening fractions of a second between quiet and gunfire, nothing is clear-cut, and blood is pumping furiously. Even 50 shots can be squeezed off in a matter of seconds.
Cooperative agreement between SPIEGEL ONLINE and the "New York Times"SPIEGEL ONLINE and the online version of the "New York Times" offer their readers a special service. Approximately twice a week, you can read selected analyses and commentary from the "New York Times" on SPIEGEL ONLINE. In return, our colleagues in New York will publish selected and translated articles from DER SPIEGEL on their website each week."We can teach as much as we can," said John C. Cerar, a retired commander of the Police Department's firearms training section. "The fog of the moment happens. Different things happen that people don't understand. Most people really believe what it's like in television, that a police officer can take a gun and shoot someone out of the saddle."
The five officers involved in the shooting were placed on administrative duty yesterday - without their guns - as the Police Department and the Queens district attorney investigated the circumstances surrounding the shooting, and relatives of Mr. Bell, joined by the Rev. Al Sharpton, staged a rally and a march to demand answers.
The officers have not yet been interviewed by police investigators or prosecutors to give their account.
Again and again, the focus of the day returned to the number of bullets that went flying.
One of the officers fired more than half the rounds, pausing to reload, and then emptying it again, 31 shots in all, according to the police. Another officer fired 11 shots. The others fired four shots, three shots and one shot apiece, the police said.
But it is the total number of shots that shook and angered the families of the men and community leaders. "How many shots?" Mr. Sharpton asked yesterday, over and over, in a chant at a rally in a park near Mary Immaculate Hospital, where the wounded men were being treated. The crowd called back, "Fifty!"
Statistically, the shooting is an aberration. The number of shots fired per officer who acted in the 112 shooting incidents this year, through Nov. 19, is 3.2, said Paul J. Browne, a department spokesman. Last year, that number was 3.7 shots fired per officer in 109 incidents. They are down from 4.6 in 2000 and 5.0 in 1995.
But shootings with high numbers of shots fired, however rare, call to mind dark events of the city's past, like the 1999 killing of Gidone Busch, who was clutching a hammer when officers fired 12 times, and, most notably, the shooting of Amadou Diallo, an unarmed West African immigrant who died in a hail of 41 bullets, also in 1999.
In the 1995 Bronx bodega robbery in which officers fired 125 shots, the suspects did not fire back. "They were shooting to the echo of their own gunfire," a former police official said at the time.
The shooting on Saturday unfolded in a flash. An undercover officer posted inside the Club Kalua, a site of frequent drug, weapon and prostitution complaints in Jamaica, overheard an exchange between a stripper and a man that led the officer to suspect the man was armed, Police Commissioner Raymond W. Kelly said on Saturday. The undercover officer alerted the officers acting as backup outside - there were seven officers in all - about 4 a.m., setting into motion the events to follow later.
Eight men left the club and argued briefly with another man, with one from the group saying, "Yo, get my gun," Mr. Kelly said.
The eight men apparently split into two groups of four, with one group piling into a Nissan Altima driven by Mr. Bell, Commissioner Kelly said. As an undercover detective who had been following the group on foot approached the vehicle, Mr. Bell drove into him, striking his leg, before plowing into a minivan carrying two backup officers, the commissioner said.
The Altima reversed, mounting a sidewalk and hitting the lowered gate of a building before going forward and striking the van again. The officers opened fire, striking Mr. Bell, 23, twice, in the right arm and neck, Commissioner Kelly said. The critically wounded man, Joseph Guzman, 31, was struck 11 times, and the third man, Trent Benefield, 23, three times. Mr. Kelly said it was unclear whether there was a fourth man in the car and what became of him.
A person familiar with the case who knows the detectives' version of events said yesterday that it was Mr. Guzman who asked for his gun, and that the first undercover detective on foot clearly identified himself to the occupants of the car and, gun drawn, told them to get out. Instead, the person said, they roared toward him. That detective fired the first shot.
In the ensuing barrage, one shot struck the window of a house, another a window at an AirTrain platform, injuring two Port Authority police officers with flying glass. It appeared that the Altima was struck by 21 shots, fewer than half of the number fired, the police said.
The whole thing most likely took less than a minute. The officer who fired 31 times could have done so in fewer than 20 seconds, with the act of reloading taking less than one second, Mr. Cerar said. The 49 shots that followed the undercover detective's first may have been contagious shooting, said one former police official who insisted on anonymity because the investigation is continuing.
"He shoots, and you shoot, and the assumption is he has a good reason for shooting. You saw it in Diallo. You see it in a lot of shootings," the official said. "You just chime in. I don't mean the term loosely. But you see your partner, and your reflexes take over."
The phenomenon of officers' firing dozens of shots at a time dates back in part to 1993 and the department's switch from six-shot .38-caliber revolvers, cumbersome to reload, to semiautomatic pistols that hold 15 rounds in the magazine and one in the chamber. The change, like any of its magnitude, followed years of studies and differences of opinion, and finally came into effect after the 1986 murder of a police officer, Scott Gadell, who was reloading his six-shooter when he was fatally shot.
Commissioner Kelly, during his first term in the office, in 1992 and 1993, ordered a switch to semiautomatics, but ordered the clips modified to hold only 10 rounds. That modification was later undone, prompting him, after Mr. Diallo's shooting six years later, to speculate in a New York Times op-ed article, "Now may be the time to re-impose it and to intensify training that teaches police officers to hold their fire until they know why they are shooting."
Eugene O'Donnell, a professor of police studies at John Jay College, said a high number of shots fired underscores the threat the officers felt.
"The only reason to be shooting in New York City is that you or someone else is going to be killed and it's going to be imminent," he said. "It's highly unlikely you fire a shot or two shots. You fire as many shots as you have to, to extinguish the threat. You don't fire one round and say: 'Did I hit him? Is he hit?' "
Mr. Cerar said, "Until we have some substitute for a firearm, there will always be a situation where more rounds are fired than in other situations."
William K. Rashbaum contributed reporting.
© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2006

Thursday, November 23, 2006

10 November 2006
RUMSFELD - THE MAN WHO WOULD NOT LISTEN
By Christopher Hitchens
IS IT only five years since the society columns in Washington were describing Donald Rumsfeld as “hot”, and printing stories about how ladies of a certain age wanted his phone number?
The aplomb he displayed during the campaign in Afghanistan, and the way he seemed to enjoy his press conferences, were just the tonic that the country appeared to need after the humiliation and panic of 11 September.
It didn’t hurt that the Secretary of Defence had been seen in his shirt-sleeves, helping direct rescue operations after a plane ploughed into the Pentagon.
As the Taliban fled and Afghans greeted American soldiers as liberators, the escape of Osama bin-Laden was a detail that could be taken care of later, and “Rummy” seemed able to do no wrong.
By this month, it seemed not only that he could do nothing right, but that everything that had gone wrong was his fault.
Surveying the hell that is today’s Baghdad, who can avoid wincing at his offhand remark that “stuff happens?” The situation would be just as bad if he had not said that, but his breezy refusal to face facts had come to symbolize an Administration that did not learn from its mistakes.
Or from its crimes – the horrors of Abu Ghreib and the lawlessness of Guantanamo and “extraordinary rendition” also became associated with a Rumsfeldian smile that began to look more like an irritating smirk than a confident grin.
He once told me that he was the only man in Washington who was still doing the same job as he was doing 30 years ago (he was at the Pentagon under President Ford) and that cadets whose graduation he had once attended were now wearing four stars. This ought perhaps to have led him to “bond” better with the soldiers under his command, but the fact is that his subordinates came to resent him.
Stories emerged from the office about his reluctance to listen, about his outbursts of bad temper, and about the now-legendary “snowflakes” – the blizzard of memos with which he showered the building. Rumsfeld is essentially a businessman, and many CEOs have the fond illusion that government departments, and even wars in faraway countries, can be run in the same way as a firm.
It is already obvious that his plan for a leaner and more streamlined military will enter the history books as a calamitous refusal to deploy enough troops to stay any possible course in Iraq.
One does not get a second chance to make a good first impression, and it now looks as if almost everything that went wrong in Iraq went wrong right from the start. This might possibly have been forgivable or correctable, but the continuing under-estimation of the insurgency (and the wave of the hand with which the Iraqi army was dismissed) will always be remembered, as will the complaints from serving soldiers that they were not issued with things – such as body-armour – which a thoughtful chief executive might have been expected to have provided for them.
Much is made of Rumsfeld’s earlier career as a wrestler: a sport in which pinning is all and compromise superfluous. These qualities could actually be very useful in wartime, but not if the original strategy is mistaken. A good wrestler is supposed to be able to use the opponent’s strength against him: something the United States has experienced in reverse in Iraq.
The last time I attended a Rumsfeld briefing, I got a slight glimpse of the problem.
To every question or suggestion or criticism, he responded as if it was a brilliant idea that exactly confirmed what he had just been saying. After a while, this stopped being curious and became slightly alarming. The Secretary of Defence, it occurred to me, had plenty of body-armour but it was protecting him from seeing or hearing anything that he didn’t like.
This is a quality that can get you a long way – including a very long way in the wrong direction.
Christopher Hitchens is a columnist for Vanity Fair
Print Close

Sunday, November 05, 2006


Disgraced Haggard: I am a "deceiver and a liar"
By Eric GorskiDenver Post Staff Writer DenverPost.com
In a letter of apology read to the congregation of New Life Church Sunday morning, Ted Haggard confessed to sexual immorality and described himself as "a deceiver and a liar."
"There is a part of my life that is so repulsive and dark that I've been warring against it all of my adult life," Haggard wrote.
Describing a lifelong battle against temptations that were contrary to his teachings, Haggard said he had sought assistance "in a variety of ways," and while he had stretches of "freedom," nothing proved effective.
Haggard was fired as senior pastor of the church on Saturday by an oversight board of pastors that concluded Haggard committed "sexually immoral conduct." The board had investigated claims by a male prostitute who said publicly this week that Haggard paid him for sex and took methamphetamine over a three-year period.
"The accusations that have been leveled against me are not all true, but enough of them are true that I have been appropriately and lovingly removed from ministry," Haggard wrote.
Haggard asked the congregation of the church he founded 26 years ago to forgive him. He also told church members not to be angry at his accuser, instead urging them to thank God for him.
"He didn't violate you; I did," Haggard said.
While the letter was read, more than 7,000 people in attendance sat in silence, some of them weeping. The letter was read by Larry Stockstill, who leads a church outside Baton Rouge, La., that is considered the "mother church of New Life."
After the letter was read, there was brief applause with a smattering of people standing.
In deciding to dismiss Haggard, the oversight board consulted with several evangelical leaders, including James Dobson of Focus on the Family and Jack Hayford, a prominent preacher from southern California, Stockstill said.
Stockstill tried to reassure church members their institution was safe and secure, despite Haggard's removal as leader. The decision to dismiss Haggard, rather than discipline him, actually came as a relief to "Pastor Ted" and his wife, Stockstill said.
"That is not a harsh thing, that's a wonderful thing for him," Stockstill said.
In his letter, Haggard said he added to the confusion this week when speaking to reporters about the allegations against him. He acknowledged "inconsistent statements" for which he was solely responsible.
"The fact is, I am guilty of sexual immorality, and I take responsibility for the entire problem," he wrote.
Haggard said he and his wife, Gayle, "need to be gone for a while," and will never return to a leadership role at New Life Church.
Gayle Haggard also released a letter to the congregation. In it, she professed her commitment to her marriage and her belief in the teachings of the church.
"I would not change one iota of what I have been teaching the women of our church," Gayle Haggard wrote. "For those of you who have been concerned that my marriage was so perfect I could not possibly relate to the women who are facing great difficulties, know that this will never again be the case.
"My test has begun; watch me. I will try to prove myself faithful."

Saturday, November 04, 2006

Evangelical ousted amid gay sex scandal
KIM NGUYENAssociated Press
COLORADO SPRINGS, Colo. - The Rev. Ted Haggard was dismissed Saturday as leader of the megachurch he founded after a board determined the influential evangelist had committed "sexually immoral conduct," the church said.
Haggard had resigned two days earlier as president of the National Association of Evangelicals, where he held sway in Washington and condemned homosexuality, after a Denver man named Mike Jones claimed to have had drug-fueled trysts with him. He also had placed himself on administrative leave from the New Life Church, but its Overseer Board took the stronger action Saturday.
"Our investigation and Pastor Haggard's public statements have proven without a doubt that he has committed sexually immoral conduct," the independent board said in a statement.
Haggard was "informed of this decision," the statement said, and he "agreed as well that he should be dismissed."
Haggard, 50, on Friday acknowledged paying Jones for a massage and for methamphetamine, but said he did not have sex with him and did not take the drug.
The statement from the 14,000-member church said the investigation would continue to determine the extent of the misconduct. The Rev. Mike Ware of Victory Church in Westminster, a member of the board, declined to characterize what investigators found but said the board did not talk to Jones.
Haggard did not answer his home or mobile phones Saturday, and neither was accepting messages. The Rev. Rob Brendle, an associate pastor at New Life, said Haggard was out of town.
"We are fully confident in the board's judgment and decision," Brendle said. "Everyone supports Ted and his family. We stand by him."
Jones said the news of Haggard's dismissal made him sad.
"I feel really bad for his wife and family and his congregation. I know it's a sad day for them, too," Jones said. "I feel bad when someone has so many attachments to others. It affects everyone. I'm certainly not cheering or jumping up and down over what's happened.
"I just hope the family has peace and can come to terms with things. I hope they can continue with a happy life."
The Rev. Ross Parsley will lead the church until a permanent replacement for Haggard is chosen by the end of the year, the statement said. A letter explaining Haggard's removal and an apology from him will be read at Sunday services.
Haggard's situation is a disappointment to Christian conservatives, whom President Bush and other Republicans are courting heavily in the run-up to Tuesday's election.
Many were already disheartened with the president and the Republican-controlled Congress over their failure to deliver big gains on social issues even before the congressional page scandal involving former Rep. Mark Foley.
Haggard, who had been president of the evangelical association since 2003, has participated in conference calls with White House staffers and lobbied Congress last year on Supreme Court nominees.
Haggard visited the White House once or twice, Deputy Press Secretary Tony Fratto said Friday.
Richard Cizik, the evangelical association's vice president for governmental affairs, called Haggard's ouster "heartbreaking and unfortunate."
"He is a man who has done a lot of good and who hopefully after a period of repentance and counsel and spiritual restoration will have a future ministry at some point," Cizik said.
The association has named President Leith Anderson, senior pastor of Wooddale Church in Eden Prairie, Minn., as its interim president.
The board's decision cuts Haggard off from leadership of the massive church he founded in the mid-1980s. He held New Life's first services in the unfinished basement of his Colorado Springs home.
Jones, who said he is gay, said he was upset when he discovered who Haggard was and found out that the New Life Church had publicly opposed same-sex marriage - a key issue in Colorado, with a pair of issues on Tuesday's ballot.
"It made me angry that here's someone preaching about gay marriage and going behind the scenes having gay sex," Jones said.
Jones has denied selling drugs but said Haggard snorted methamphetamine before their sexual encounters to heighten his experience. Jones agreed to take a lie-detector test Friday; the administrator of the test said the answers about his sex allegations "indicated deception."
But Jones said Saturday: "Obviously they determined there was sexual indiscretions, so I think that vindicates my claim."
Haggard told reporters he bought meth but never used it; he said he received a massage from Jones after being referred to him by a Denver hotel. Jones said that no hotel referred Haggard and that he advertises only in gay publications.
In a TV interview this week, Haggard said: "Never had a gay relationship with anybody, and I'm steady with my wife, I'm faithful to my wife."
Church member Christine Rayes, 47, said the congregation had hoped the allegations "were all lies."
"We all have to move forward now," she said. "This doesn't make what Ted accomplished here any less. The farther up you are, the more you are a target for Satan."

Friday, November 03, 2006

Key Evangelical quits amid gay sex claim
CATHERINE TSAI
Associated Press
COLORADO SPRINGS, Colo. - The president of the National Association of Evangelicals, an outspoken opponent of gay marriage, has given up his post while a church panel investigates allegations he paid a man for sex.
The Rev. Ted Haggard resigned as president of the 30 million-member association Thursday after being accused of paying the man for monthly trysts over the past three years.
Haggard, a married father of five, denied the allegations, but also stepped aside as head of his 14,000-member New Life Church pending an investigation.
"I am voluntarily stepping aside from leadership so that the overseer process can be allowed to proceed with integrity," he said in a statement. "I hope to be able to discuss this matter in more detail at a later date. In the interim, I will seek both spiritual advice and guidance."
Carolyn Haggard, spokeswoman for the New Life Church and the pastor's niece, said a four-member church panel will investigate the allegations. The board has the authority to discipline Haggard, including removing him from ministry work.
The acting senior pastor at New Life, Ross Parsley, told KKTV-TV of Colorado Springs that Haggard admitted that some of the accusations were true.
"I just know that there has been some admission of indiscretion, not admission to all of the material that has been discussed but there is an admission of some guilt," Parsley told the station.
He did not elaborate, and a telephone number for Parsley could not be found late Thursday.
The allegations come as voters in Colorado and seven other states get ready to decide Tuesday on amendments banning gay marriage. Besides the proposed ban on the Colorado ballot, a separate measure would establish the legality of domestic partnerships providing same-sex couples with many of the rights of married couples.
The allegations stunned church members.
"It's political, right before the elections," said Brian Boals, a New Life member for 17 years.
Church member E.J. Cox, 25, called the claims "ridiculous."
"People are always saying stuff about Pastor Ted," she said. "You just sort of blow it off. He's just like anyone else in the public eye."
The accusations were made by Mike Jones, 49, of Denver, who said he decided to go public because of the political fight over the amendments.
"I just want people to step back and take a look and say, 'Look, we're all sinners, we all have faults, but if two people want to get married, just let them, and let them have a happy life,'" said Jones, who added that he isn't working for any political group.
Jones, who said he is gay, said he was also upset when he discovered Haggard and the New Life Church had publicly opposed same-sex marriage.
"It made me angry that here's someone preaching about gay marriage and going behind the scenes having gay sex," he said.
Jones claimed Haggard paid him to have sex nearly every month over three years. He said he advertised himself as an escort on the Internet and was contacted by a man who called himself Art, who snorted methamphetamine before their sexual encounters to heighten his experience.
Jones said he later saw the man on television identified as Haggard and that the two last had sex in August.
He said he has voice mail messages from Haggard, as well as an envelope he said Haggard used to mail him cash. He declined to make the voice mails available to the AP, but KUSA-TV reported what it said were excerpts late Thursday that referred to methamphetamine.
"Hi Mike, this is Art," one call began, according to the station. "Hey, I was just calling to see if we could get any more. Either $100 or $200 supply."
A second message, left a few hours later, began: "Hi Mike, this is Art, I am here in Denver and sorry that I missed you. But as I said, if you want to go ahead and get the stuff, then that would be great. And I'll get it sometime next week or the week after or whenever."
Haggard, 50, was appointed president of the evangelicals association in March 2003. He has participated in conservative Christian leaders' conference calls with White House staffers and lobbied members of Congress last year on U.S. Supreme Court appointees after Sandra Day O'Connor announced her retirement.
After Massachusetts legalized gay marriage in 2004, Haggard and others began organizing state-by-state opposition. Last year, Haggard and officials from the nearby Christian ministry Focus on the Family announced plans to push Colorado's gay marriage ban for the 2006 ballot.
At the time, Haggard said that he believed marriage is a union between a man and woman rooted in centuries of tradition, and that research shows it's the best family unit for children.
---
Associated Press Writer Dan Elliott contributed to this report from Denver.

Wednesday, November 01, 2006



Last of the apartheid-era hardliners, the 'Great Crocodile' of Afrikaner politics who arguably destroyed the National Party
P. W. BOTHA, the eighth Prime Minister and the first State President of South Africa, was a contradictory figure. Although he admitted that the apartheid state “must adapt or die” and introduced constitutional reforms that brought Coloured and Asian representation into Parliament and the Cabinet, he also ignored the demands of Africans and supervised the brutal crackdown on violent anti-apartheid unrest that had threatened to render South Africa ungovernable. He famously wagged his finger in 1985 during the Rubicon speech, declaring to the opponents as well as to the friends of apartheid South Africa: “Don’t push us too far.”
Nevertheless, history may well judge that P. W. Botha rather than F. W. de Klerk destroyed the unity of the National Party (NP) that had ruled South Africa since 1948. The Groot Krokodil (Great Crocodile) of Afrikaner politics dominated the defence of the nation for 23 years from his appointment as Minister of Defence in 1966 to his retirement in 1989.
Pieter Willem Botha was born in the Orange Free State in 1916. He studied law at Grey University College, later the University of the Orange Free State, leaving without a degree. He quickly became active in National Party politics in the Cape. Legend has it that as a 20-year-old political organiser he broke up United Party meetings while sitting astride a horse. In 1939, he joined the Ossewabrandwag, the extremist paramilitary organisation that supported Nazi Germany during the Second World War. Botha avoided internment when he broke away from the organisation, accusing it of meddling in National Party affairs. After the war his political rise continued: in 1948, after the NP victory over Jan Smuts’s United Party, P. W., Secretary of the Cape National Party, was elected as an MP for the Cape constituency of George.
In 1958 Hendrik Verwoerd,apartheid’s visionary leader, appointed Botha Deputy Minister of Internal Affairs, and in 1961 he entered the Cabinet as Minister of Community Development and Coloured Affairs.
In April 1966, five months before Verwoerd’s assassination, Botha became Minister of Defence. In the same year, he was elected leader of the National Party in the Cape. Helen Suzman recalled in her memoir Botha’s vicious reaction to the murder of the Prime Minister. He screamed across the chamber: “It’s you who did this. It’s all you liberals. You incite people. Now we will get you. We will get the lot of you.”
Between 1966 and 1978, Botha built strong power bases in the Cape and the South African military. Despite the embarrassment of presiding over South Africa’s intervention in Angola in 1975 and rapid withdrawal in 1976, Botha was at the centre of a maelstrom of theory and planning in the mid-1970s.
In 1975, launching the Defence White Paper, he declared: “Defence strategy embraces much more than military strategy. It involves economy, ideology, technology, and even social matters and can therefore only be meaningful and valid if proper account is taken of all these other spheres . . . This, in fact, is the meaning of Total Strategy.” During the 1980s, the Total Strategy would lead to “securicrats”, as the security officials became known, interfering in almost every aspect of South African society in a flailing attempt to avoid the collapse of apartheid. At the end of 1976, Botha chaired a special Cabinet Commitee investigating the possibility of constutional change. His report in 1977 recommended an elected executive presidency and separate parliaments for Whites, Coloureds and Asians.
P. W. Botha was elected Prime Minister of South Africa in 1978 during the Information scandal (also known as Muldergate) that eventually destroyed the careers and reputations of Prime Minister John Vorster, the most likely successor, Connie Mulder; Hendrik van den Bergh,the head of Boss, the South African Secret Service; and Eschel Rhoodie, the Secretary of Information. After a closely fought leadership campaign, which opponents likened to a military coup, Botha came to power as the head of a divided NP. Profound tensions existed between the verkramptes, who wanted a return to the rigidly doctrinaire application of apartheid. and the verligtes, who believed that the ideology should be adapted to suit changing circumstances. Botha was numbered among the verligtes despite his muscular image as Minister of Defence. The ideological differences proved intractable and in March 1982 Dr Andries Treurnicht, the leader of the Transvaal NP, established the Conservative Party with 16 MPs. The broedertwis (brotherly conflict) had been exacerbated by Botha’s proposals to allow Coloured and Asian representation in a tricameral Parliament.
Botha rewarded the South African Defence Force (SADF) with a posioned chalice. While the defence budget grew exponentially during both his period as Defence Minister and later as Prime Minister/President, he also expected the military to become involved in South African politics. Preaching “hearts and minds” while waging war at home and in neighbouring countries was never likely to be a recipe for success. Meanwhile, the Military Intelligence Division dominated South Africa’ s international intelligence gathering. For every success such as the meeting with Margaret Thatcher at Chequers in 1984 or the Nkomati Accord (of the same year) under which Mozambique agreed not to allow the African National Congress to operate from its territory and the South Africans undertook to withdraw support for Renamo, there was a multitude of brutal interventions in Mozambique, Zimbabwe, Lestotho, Botswana and Angola which achieved little. Nicknamed Piet Wapens (Weapons) by NP colleagues during his tenure as Minister of Defence, Botha’s enemies in the Department of Information called him Pangaman (Macheteman), “because you never knew when he was going to lash out at you”.
His standing as a reformist leader at home and abroad disintegrated as the violence, that erupted in the African townships in late 1984 spread throughout the country. In July 1985, Botha declared a partial state of emergency, which in June 1986 was extended to a full state of emergency. As the South African economy collapsed after the Chase Manhattan Bank’s refusal to roll over its loans and the rand lost half its value against sterling, it became obvious to informed observers that the apartheid state would be forced to negotiate with the African opposition. Botha refused to lift the bans on the major African political organisations, the ANC and the Pan Africanist Congress, and insisted that they must renounce violence before there could be any question of negotiation or the release of Nelson Mandela and his colleagues.
In addition to the brutal police action that was required to control the insurrection in the townships, the Government instituted press censorship and large-scale detention without trial. Tens of thousands of people were subjected to the full brunt of apartheid justice. Meanwhile, apartheid death squads targeted individuals. One State Security Council document, later discovered by Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) researchers revealed that in July 1985: “The chairman (Botha) points out that he is convinced that the brain behind the unrest situation is situated inside South Africa, and that it must be found and destroyed.”
In May 1986 a delegation of Commonwealth notables, known as the Eminent Persons’ Group, visited South Africa, hoping to facilitate negotiation. The group left South Africa without meeting the President, however, amid rumours of a split between doves and hawks in the Cabinet. While the group was still in Cape Town, the SADF launched raids on neighbouring Commonwealth states. Within months, the United States passed the Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act and sanctions packages were also adopted by Britain, the Commonwealth and the European Community.
Towards the end of 1987 it became clear that Botha was facing critical choices in his regional policy. The SADF, which had invaded Angola on numerous occasions during the 1980s to bolster Jonas Savimbi’s Unita against the Cuban-supported Angolan MPLA government, reached an impasse at the battle of Cuito Cuanavale. Realising that sanctions had finally had their effect (South Africa had lost air superiority) and that the SADF was risking the loss of many white soldiers, Botha opted for peace, reportedly on the basis of a cost-benefit analysis. Under pressure from both the United States and the Soviet Union, South Africa and Angola sought a diplomatic resolution to the Angolan war.
Botha has rarely received praise for his attempts to reform apartheid but it was under his leadership that the South African state abolished the pass laws which restricted the movement of Africans in the country, legalised interracial marriages, and gave the nod to the formation of black trade unions. But he remained contradictory until the end: in February 1988, seventeen anti-apartheid organisations were banned. Three months later, the first formal meetings between the imprisoned Mandela and a government team of negotiators started in Pollsmoor prison.
On 18 January, 1989, Botha suffered a mild stroke and was advised by his doctors to rest for six weeks. Members of his family insist to this day that he was poisoned by a member of his own Cabinet. A few weeks later Botha took the country, and even his closest colleagues, by surprise when he sent a message to the National Party’s parliamentary caucus announcing that he ws resigning as party leader. He intended, however, to retain his position as State President. It was a situation designed for disaster and following the election of F. W. de Klerk, the NP voted in favour of the leader of the party occupying the office of the State President. Botha grudgingly accepted that he would retire after the general election in September 1989 but after a five-month sulk, he appeared on South African television to announce that, since he was being ignored by his Cabinet, he had no choice but to resign. In the midst of this extraordinary interregnum, Botha met Mandela. The two leaders claimed to like each other, Botha later commenting that he believed that Mandela was a communist but he respected him as a gentleman and a Xhosa chief.
Botha retired to the aptly named Wilderness near his former constituency of George. He rarely granted interviews and managed to avoid facing the consequences of his actions in power.
Pieter Willem Botha, first State President of South Africa, 1984-1989, was born on January 12, 1916. He died on October 31, 2006, aged 90

Monday, October 30, 2006

Gays abuse Australian restrooms
Sydney Morning News
The closure of customer toilets in a Myer store due to rampant homosexual activity has exposed a massive list of venues being used by members of a gay website as hook-up points.
Among the places listed as meeting spots for men "cruising for sex", on squirt.org, is the Royal Australian Air Force's Richmond base and Sydney Opera House's toilets.
Management at Myer's Sydney city store in Pitt Street were forced to close its level one toilet to the public because homosexuals were using the facility as a meeting point, often having sex in full view of other horrified users.
A Myer spokesman, Mark West, confirmed he had heard that the retailer had been mentioned on a hardcore gay porn website called squirt.org, which men used to arrange meetings at the toilet, and one month ago the store's management decided to make it a staff-only facility.The website claims to list more than 15,000 locations around Australia "where gay and bisexual guys meet for sex" and still has the Myer city store's toilet listed as a meeting place. A search of the site yielded hundreds of well-known Sydney buildings, parks and beaches.
A spokeswoman for the Department of Defence said she would look into the matter after being told about the RAAF listing, and possibly make a comment by 5pm.
A Myer staff member who spoke to smh.com.au said she had seen men running out of the toilet alerting employees about homosexual activity, while others had complained about being propositioned.
"I wouldn't let my friend's young son go in there, no way. I was really worried about his safety," she said. "There were men going in and out all the time. You'd see them come out, and say 'Woops, I forgot my mobile or wallet', and then go back in. I'd see men sitting on the chair near the toilet just waiting.
"It's been happening for years. I know they were making plans on a website to meet here."
A security guard in the store said the toilet had to be closed because "we had problems with people in there ... there were safety issues". Asked if the problem was due to men using the toilet as a hook-up point, he replied: "The whole city has got that problem."
Mr West said: "There has been a range of security concerns surrounding that toilet and we have closed it pending a review. There were some customer concerns about anti-social activity in there. Ideally we wouldn't have had to close it; it is a temporary measure."We are reviewing security, there is certainly no risk for customers."
Other prominent places used by subscribers of the website include the toilets of Westfield stores and Marrickville Metro, the library at the University of NSW, various Fitness First gyms, and Bankstown Airport's rest area.Comment is awaited from various Fitness First gyms and Westfield stores.
Another is the Crows Nest Community Centre, which it seems is extremely popular, with 100 comments posted from the website's users regarding the site. The centre's chief executive officer, Michelle Boston, was unaware of any incidents in the listed ground floor toilets, and was appalled when told by smh.com.au.
"This is awful," she said. "We have so many vulnerable people that come here."
Within 30 minutes of being informed, Ms Boston phoned smh.com.au back and said: "I have taken immediate action. All toilets are now locked. People will have to report to reception to get a key. All children who use the facility will have to be accompanied by a parent. We care about our community and do not want them put at risk."

Sunday, October 22, 2006



The Sunday Times
October 22, 2006
Conrad the Barbarian
Tom Bower reveals the childhood traumas behind the excesses of Conrad Black, the former press baron facing a multi-million fraud trial and prison
Domestic life was remarkably agreeable for the newly married Conrad Black and Barbara Amiel in 1990s London. Both tended to work late into the night and rise at noon. Drinking ginger tea and eating chocolate biscuits made by his chef, the proprietor of The Daily Telegraph spent hours on the telephone while Amiel struggled with her newspaper column, sometimes taking three days to complete 1,300 words in her office on the top floor of their mansion in Cottesmore Gardens, Kensington.
The huge house bought in 1992 brazenly suggested the wealth and influence of a billionaire. Their audience — London’s rich and powerful — took the impersonation seriously. But those who observed them closely were less impressed.
Simon Heffer, a columnist on Black’s Telegraph, observed: “Barbara has turned Conrad from an homme sérieux into a society petal. He’s besotted with her, like a spaniel.”
Hal Jackman, a rich investor and disillusioned old friend, labelled Black “a parvenu drifting away from reality. I can’t understand his priorities. He does too much entertaining and not enough business”.
Black was unrepentant. He had other homes — and other friends — in New York, Toronto and Palm Beach.
The facade lasted for a decade. In 2001, about to be ennobled, Black showed a real billionaire, the Canadian gold magnate Peter Munk, his beautifully refurbished Rolls-Royce Silver Wraith. It had purple leather “like the Queen’s”.
“How can you afford it?” asked Munk. Black smiled.
In reality, the wheels were coming off for the new Lord and Lady Black; and friends were deserting them. Last year, accused of defrauding his companies of hundreds of millions of dollars to support his extravagant lifestyle, and facing a fight to stay out of jail, Black needed money. He called several friends in New York.
“Do you think you can get a group of people together if the need arises,” he asked one billionaire, “and get me some funds secured against my property?” “How much do you want from everyone, Conrad?” asked the businessman.
“About $1m each,” said Black.
There was a pause. “You’re my best friend,” continued Black. “Surely you can lend me $1m?”
“Well, Conrad,” said the man, “what’s my private telephone number?”
“I don’t know,” replied Black. “Why?”
“Well, if I were your best friend, you’d have it.”
The first to refuse any contribution outright was Alfred Taubman, who had himself done jail-time for price-fixing while chairman of Sotheby’s. The rest followed suit. They were disdainful of a man famous for his excesses and the collapse of his empire rather than for his achievements.
Black remained unrepentant. At 1.15am on April 1 this year he sent me an e-mail. I had known him since the mid-1980s, and now I was writing a book about him. Well over 200 people had agreed to be interviewed for it. Their generosity is a principal source of my information.
“Dear Tom,” Black wrote. “Many people have contacted Barbara and me asking if they should talk with you.
“Our usual response is that you have made it clear that you consider this whole matter a heart-warming story of two sleazy, spivvy, contemptible people, who enjoyed a fraudulent and unjust elevation; were exposed, and ground to powder in a just system; have been ostracised, and largely impoverished; and that I am on my way to the prison cell where I belong.
“The rough facts are that I am an honest businessman; the chances of my committing an illegality are less than zero, this will be clear when my accusers have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt the guilt of innocent people and not just manipulate the agencies of the US and Canadian governments to act on the pre-emptive presumption of guilt and conduct a prolonged assassination of careers and reputations.”
Convinced of his acquittal, Black pledged himself in the second e-mail of the night to wreak vengeance upon those responsible for his demise: “We will bring this entire, gigantic, malicious persecution down around the ears of its authors.”
He was, he wrote later that night, proud of his robustness. And in yet another e-mail the same night, he keenly anticipated the stardom that he would achieve at his trial, due to start in Chicago in March 2007. It would be “spectacular”.
Black’s life story is not the familiar tale of a tycoon’s rise and fall, or the tragedy of a self-delusional fantasist. Rather, it is the drama of a plutocrat who stands accused as a kleptocrat. The riddle is just how he has found himself in this position.
Privilege and prejudice were Conrad Black’s roots from his birth on August 25, 1944. By the age of five, he was cosseted by cooks, butlers, nannies and chauffeurs. In the winter holidays he escaped Toronto’s freeze in the Bahamas where he gazed with his father, George Black, at the Mellons, du Ponts and other American magnates.
Although George Black did not rank among the super-rich, he was a successful businessman with an astute intellect. He noted his son’s exceptional memory and became preoccupied with creating an extraordinary individual out of him.
Obsessively he ordered Conrad to recall facts, both relevant and irrelevant. After intensive games of chess, his son was encouraged to read encyclopedias and recall what he read. His bedrooms were filled with books about the military, wars and politics. In the midst of the Korean war the boy sat transfixed listening to radio news broadcasts, and watched television reports of the McCarthy hearings in Washington targeted at unearthing communist sympathisers.
During all-night sessions, which started in Conrad’s childhood, George Black regaled his son with stories of his business struggles as president of Canadian Breweries. He had savagely cut costs, dismissed staff and created phenomenal growth. Sales and profits had tripled, and it had become the world’s biggest brewery, embracing Canada, the USA and Britain.
There was a downside to this story, however. Insomniac and increasingly intoxicated, George Black would arrive in his office at midday, boasting that because he delegated authority his presence was not required. In reality, “delegation” had become his excuse to recover from hangovers and the morning’s vodka.
When in 1958 George Black challenged the trade unions to remove their restrictive practices, they responded with an acrimonious strike that hit profits, and he was fired by the owners of the company.
Henceforth at their all-night sessions, he imbued his son with a mission to exact revenge. There would be many bitter lectures over the years on history, power and finance which inculcated in Conrad the importance of supremacy and manipulation.
Stifled by depression, George Black failed to appreciate the burden he was inflicting upon his son. He offered no physical affection, and his wife was similarly cold and remote. In that loveless atmosphere, Conrad compensated for his emotional insecurity by revelling in the lives of historic heroes. Entitlement bred defiance and insolence, fashioning a personality that enjoyed a fight and savoured inflicting defeat.
At the time that his father was fired, the unsporting, overweight boy was 14 and a pupil at Toronto’s Upper Canada College, one of the country’s elite private schools, taken there every day in a chauffeur-driven Cadillac. Months later, he was expelled for stealing exam papers and selling them. His father excused him as a “compulsive insubordinate” eager to prove his credentials as a capitalist.
Black passed through two more schools — leaving each because of misbehaviour — before being coached in a crammer to scrape a pass in his final school exams in 1962. His mediocrity reflected his laziness. He graduated from university with a poor degree three years later and failed his law exams.
His schoolboy notions of genius had been shattered. Now he had other things on his mind.
One of the men his father railed against in their nightly sessions was John “Bud” McDougald, president of the Argus corporation, the conglomerate that owned Canadian Breweries.
McDougald, championed as Canada’s supreme business leader, was in reality a financial cowboy who enjoyed a reckless lifestyle, avoiding taxes and cheating the minority shareholders. He used intimidation and flattery to disguise rampant dishonesty. Argus, a company floated on the Canadian stock exchange, was his private piggy bank.
Argus was controlled by the six principal shareholders of a private company called Ravelston, named after a Scottish estate owned by McDougald’s ancestors. While McDougald owned 23.6% of Ravelston’s shares, George Black still owned 22.4%. As a result, McDougald understood the benefits of flattering George Black’s son.
On Conrad’s 21st birthday, McDougald gave him membership of the Toronto Club, where the city’s elite fixed commercial life as they ate, drank and played.
His loyalties split, the young man practically worshipped McDougald’s mystique and power. Steeped in the minutiae of Argus’s personality conflicts and financial dubieties, he emerged with a sophisticated understanding of the inherent deception of the way in which the company was run.
Patience, planning and perfidy would be required to destroy his father’s tormentors. Meanwhile, he began in a small way as an independent businessman, buying up small weekly newspapers.
A friend introduced David Radler, a 26-year-old business-school graduate. Radler was a rough, ambitious fortune-hunter. His ratty, sharp manner and his spartan lifestyle emphasised his preoccupation with money. They complemented each other’s ambitions. Black wanted influence and wealth, while Radler enjoyed mastering the mechanics of creating that wealth. Black brought the vision of a strategy, while Radler was keen to sweat their assets. At one of their first newspapers, written complaints from staff resulted in two-cent fines for wasting paper.
The partners rarely met. “I know exactly what he’s going to do without going near what he’s doing,” said Radler. Their shared ambition for money — and Black’s for fame — cemented their relationship.
The handicap to Black’s quest for affluence was his psychological turmoil. In March 1970, he awoke to a massive anxiety attack. Sweating profusely, hyperventilating and racked by apprehension about his fate, he was on the verge, some believed, of committing suicide. The accumulation of his loveless childhood, his academic failure and his social insecurity had become an intolerable burden.
He sought help in psychoanalysis. One diagnosis suggested a narcissistic personality disorder — defined as an exaggerated sense of one’s own importance and uniqueness. Others diagnosed Black’s problems as arising from his loveless, dysfunctional home. Intense psychiatry cured him of his immediate self-destructive urge, but several personality traits remained, including a sense of his entitlement and a lack of conscience.
Later, inspired by influential figures in the Catholic Church, Black began a conversation with God. His Maker’s approval was crucial if Black was to face down those who vilified him. And God always gave His approval.
His psychological journey was interrupted by his parents’ deaths. His mother succumbed to liver cancer on June 19, 1976. Ten days later, flopped in his armchair, regularly refilling his glass with neat vodka, George Black sermonised 31-year-old Conrad on wealth and power late into the night.
In the early hours, he slowly climbed the stairs to bed. As he reached the top, Conrad Black heard cracking wood and saw his father fall over the banister onto the ground floor. Carried by Conrad into the library, George Black said that he no longer had the will to live. “Life is hell,” he told his son as they awaited the doctor. “Most people are bastards, and everything is bullshit.”
The doctor said he was unlikely to survive. Despite the prognosis, Conrad returned to his own home and watched a Charlie Chan film. He was interrupted by a telephone call. George Black was dead. Many, occasionally including his son, believed he had committed suicide.
Conrad Black was now an orphan with a purpose: to seize Ravelston, the key to the Argus corporation’s assets. McDougald and the other big shareholders, he noted, had no children. Their wives were uninterested in business. When McDougald died two years later, Black moved carefully.
McDougald’s widow, Maude, and her sister Doris, widow of another major Ravelston shareholder, lived together in Palm Beach, the Florida haven of the super-rich. Neither woman was blessed with intelligence or an understanding of business. McDougald had never bothered to explain to his wife how to cope after his death.
Black arrived to offer his assistance to the sisters, who now owned nearly half of Ravelston. The other major shareholders, he claimed, were crudely manoeuvring against the widows. “We must do something about this.”
He persuaded them to sign a contract empowering his use of their shares in any vote against the other factions. To their consternation, he then used their proxy votes to seize control of the company. Bay Street, Toronto’s financial heart, had never witnessed such a coup.
There was one more hurdle. To achieve complete ownership he needed to buy out the shocked widows’ shares. After a battle involving intimidation, stormy meetings and vicious threats, the deal was settled. For a total of $30m, he now owned a corporation controlling assets worth $4 billion.
“If my father knew what I’ve done,” he confided with pleasure, “he’d roll in his grave.”
Some “old money” families recalled his theft of examination papers. Others dubbed him “Conrad the Barbarian”. Such judgments were buried when The Globe and Mail, Toronto’s leading newspaper, made him Businessman of the Year.
It is no small irony that within a few years The Globe and Mail’s journalists were, Black believed, unfairly scrutinising his business. He complained that the newspaper was planning an article describing him as “a rapacious, right-wing Bay Street baron” who “milked” his businesses, “destroyed public companies” and oppressed minority shareholders “in a series of complex corporate shuffles designed primarily to fill his own coffers”.
In 1982, the American authorities accused him of fraudulent practices. To avoid prosecution he signed a “consent decree” promising to abide by US law. He also narrowly escaped prosecution in Canada for conspiring to defraud Argus’s shareholders.
Three years later, when he restructured his business in a succession of complicated transactions, Black appeared to his critics to have legitimately profited from asset stripping and insider dealing. Many millions of dollars were transferred from his public companies into Ravelston.
This spurred The Globe to publish its investigation. With delight, Black announced that he would sue the newspaper to “painfully punish” his critics by forcing them to prove that his dealings were dishonest. That hurdle, as The Globe’s lawyers soon discovered, would be more than difficult to surmount.
That year, 1985, was significant in other ways too. In January, he attended a party in Toronto to celebrate the third wedding of a prominent Canadian political pundit, the beautiful Barbara Amiel. Secondly, he attended the annual Bilderberg conference, a gathering of the world’s rich, famous and influential personalities.
Black and Radler were on their way to ownership of 80 newspapers across North America, and fantasised about creating an empire. To Black, buying papers meant becoming a broker of influence. He particularly enjoyed the entrée they gave him to the Bilderberg.
That year among his fellow guests was Andrew Knight, the editor of The Economist. Knight was more than a genial, successful editor. As a global networker, he was entrusted with secrets.
“Let’s have another fiery armagnac,” Black suggested to him. Over several drinks after midnight, Black confided his frustration at having failed to buy a major Canadian newspaper. Naturally, he omitted mentioning the distrust of himself in his own country.
“Canada’s a backwater,” he complained.
“If you’re looking for a big newspaper, Conrad,” replied Knight, in what would undoubtedly be the most decisive sentence ever uttered in Black’s career, “The Daily Telegraph might be a possible target.”
Too much armagnac had flowed for Knight to notice Black’s initial reaction.
© Tom Bower 2006
Extracted from Conrad and Lady Black by Tom Bower, to be published by HarperCollins on November 6 at £20. Copies can be purchased at Amazon.com

Sunday, October 15, 2006

JUVENILE JUSTICE
New claims of abuse at boys camp
As law enforcement investigates allegations of abuse, officials at the governor's office sent a team to a North Florida town to ensure the safety of juvenile delinquents.
BY CAROL MARBIN MILLER AND MARC CAPUTO
cmarbin@MiamiHerald.com
GREENVILLE - Three separate state agencies are investigating whether caretakers used banned, excessive and harmful restraints at a camp for delinquent boys, some of whom are mentally retarded or have other special needs.
At least one youth might have suffered a broken collarbone at the Greenville Hills Academy in Greenville just last week, according to records obtained by The Miami Herald. One 16-year-old claimed he was ``choked.''
And in another episode, guards also reported using a technique called a wrist lock that was banned two years ago by Anthony Schembri, secretary of the state Department of Juvenile Justice, an agency still reeling from the death of a 14year-old at another Panhandle facility earlier this year.
The DJJ is investigating Greenville along with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement and the Department of Children & Families. The agencies declined to give any details other than to confirm the investigation into the academy, which has been the subject of 30 verified abuse or neglect claims made to a state telephone hot line in two years.
''Certainly, the agency takes these allegations very seriously,'' said DJJ chief of staff Cynthia Lorenzo. ``Our top priority is the safety of youth in our care. Unfortunately, with open investigations we are unable to provide details. Once we do have all of the facts, we will take swift and appropriate action as needed, if any of our staff was involved in any wrongdoing.''
Donnie Read, who heads the youth camp's operator, Twin Oaks Juvenile Development, did not return calls from a reporter. Twin Oaks has faced unsustained allegations of abuse at another facility in Apalachicola.
`THE ACADEMY'
Simply known as ''the Academy'' in Greenville, an old railroad stop of a town in Madison County, the complex of brick buildings is topped with bright-blue roofs. It is surrounded by rolling lawns immaculately kept behind barbed wire fencing off a rural road. From a distance, the juveniles, wearing purple shirts and gray pants, look like average kids herded about summer camp by overseers clad in brick-red shirts.
One employee, who wouldn't give his name, said workers have whispered about the probe. And some think it's unfair.
''It's tough managing some of these kids. They can just go wild,'' the worker said.
Academy officers also filed three incident reports with the juvenile justice agency last week, including the one in which a teen alleged a guard ``choked him.''
PREVIOUS PROBLEMS
The camp has a history of complaints from the teens housed there. Youths filed 286 reports of abuse or neglect with the DCF child abuse hot line from September 2004 through June 2006 -- an average of about 13 reports each month, according to DCF abuse records obtained by The Miami Herald. Thirty reports were verified.
The investigation of Greenville Hills comes at a particularly sensitive time for Florida's troubled juvenile justice agency.
A special prosecutor in Tampa is nearing the end of a nearly yearlong investigation into the Jan. 6 death of Martin Lee Anderson, who officials say was asphyxiated by guards restraining him at a Panama City boot camp. An earlier official autopsy concluded that Martin died of natural causes.
BOOT CAMPS CLOSED
Lawmakers passed legislation to curb the use of physical force at five Florida boot camps, resulting in the closure of all but one.
''These are the most vulnerable kids in the system, and they're being abused,'' state Rep. Gus Barreiro, a Miami Beach Republican who heads a juvenile justice oversight committee, said of the boys housed at the moderate-risk program for ''the mentally challenged'' in Greenville, a small junction-town between Tallahassee and Jacksonville.
''These are the kids who really need our protection the most,'' he added. ``But they are being abused the most.''
A 2006 inspection of the academy, which Twin Oaks took over in July 2005, found that the camp used a behavior modification program in which youths were rewarded when they exhibited ''pro-social'' behaviors.
Though state records say Greenville Hills houses boys aged 14-18, the inspection suggested some of the boys are so young they still wet their beds.
''It should be noted that Madison cottage houses the little boys and it appears that there may be a bedwetting problem,'' the March 2006 report said, noting the cottage ``smelled of urine.''
Roy Miller, whose Tallahassee-based Florida Children's Campaign has been a vocal critic of the state's youth corrections effort, called the allegations ``very upsetting.''
'The administration has described every abuse incident as `isolated.' They are not isolated. The system is in crisis. We have gone on record as saying these programs cannot guarantee the health and safety of our children,'' Miller said.
State Rep. Mitch Needelman, a Melbourne Republican who is vice chair of the House Juvenile Justice Committee and sits on a separate DJJ oversight committee, said he was ''disappointed'' that DJJ officials failed to alert him to the investigation before a reporter started asking questions.
UNSUSTAINED CLAIMS
In May, DCF's inspector general concluded there was no evidence to sustain allegations that youths at another Twin Oaks-run facility, Apalachicola Forest Youth Camp, ''sustained serious injury'' as a result of excessive force at that Florida Panhandle camp for youths incompetent to stand trial because of mental illness or disability.
The report said, however, that eight youths had broken bones at the camp between October 2003 and March 2006, including four broken arms and two broken elbows. At least four of the injuries occurred during restraints. Twice, on Feb. 4, 2004 and Sept. 13, 2004, youths fractured elbows during ''elbow control'' restraints, the report says.
HURT DURING RESTRAINT
One Miami youth, a then-15-year-old with mental retardation who was detained at Apalachicola after being charged with molestation, suffered a spiral fracture to his left arm in December 2005, according to records obtained by The Miami Herald. A report from Tallahassee Memorial Hospital said the injury occurred during a restraint.
In all, DCF received 219 child abuse reports involving the camp since January 2002. Twenty-six of the reports were closed with either verified abuse or some ''indicators'' of abuse.
''These are somebody's kids,'' Barreiro said. ``We just can't continue to hurt these kids and expect them to come back to the community and not want to hurt other people.''

Tuesday, October 10, 2006

Plug is new contraceptive for men
By David Rose
The huge interest in trials of a possible reversible alternative to vasectomy has surprised scientists

TRIALS of a new male contraceptive are being expanded after overwhelming interest from the public.
Scientists in the United States have been taken aback by the number of men who are eager to test the method, which is potentially reversible and designed as an alternative to surgical vasectomy.
The Intra Vas Device or IVD, which is inserted via a small hole made in the scrotum, uses a tiny plug of silicone gel that blocks sperm from travelling along the each of the tubes connecting the testicles and the penis, known as the vas deferens.
In a pilot study involving 30 men the IVD was effective in preventing conception. Studies in monkeys have also shown that it is reversible.
Extensive tests are now needed to check if the method is reversible in men using the device for years rather than months.
A traditional vasectomy, where the vasa deferntia are tied or cut, can be reversed in some men, but it is designed to be permanent.
Elaine Lissner, of the non-profit Male Contraceptive Information Project in San Francisco, said: “It is a lot easier to pull the plugs out than to find the best, most expensive microsurgeon to sew a vas deferens back together. But even if you can get sperm flowing again, the chances of pregnancy go down by about 10 per cent for each year the man had the vasectomy. Only time will tell if it’s the same for IVD.”
Ms Lissner said men increasingly want to take responsibility and control for the use of contraception. A recent study of more than 9,000 men in nine countries suggested more than 60 per cent of men in countries such as Spain, Germany, Mexico and Brazil would like to relieve their partners of some of the burden of using contraception in their relationship or would like a reliable back-up to condoms.
Surgeons testing the IVD injected a silicone gel through the skin of the scrotum directly into the vas deferens, where it will block the sperm. The main concern is the build- up of pressure behind the silicone plug, which could damage the sperm production glands in the testes.
Shepherd Medical Company will begin testing its IVD next week. Originally the researchers had planned to include male volunteers from St Paul, Minnesota, but have expanded the trials because of the high demand.
All the men taking part have finished having families and would otherwise have desired a vasectomy, the researchers said. The evaluation group will test the IVD for two years.
British regulators said they were not aware of any similar trials planned.
Other scientists have been searching for less invasive and reversible male contraceptives based on hormones that could be taken in the same way as the female Pill.
Richard Anderson, of the University of Edinburgh, who has been investigating hormonal male contraceptives, said: “This would be a very attractive alternative to vasectomy. But even if it is potentially reversible after a few years, it would still not be a contraceptive that could be put in and taken out repeatedly for spacing your family, for example.”
Researchers in China are working on a mesh-like vas deferens plug that allows small amounts of sperm through, not enough to cause a pregnancy, which could get round problems from sperm build-up.
BIRTH CONTROL WITHOUT TEARS
About 18 per cent of men aged 16 to 69 have had a vasectomy, which involves cutting the vas deferens tubes between the testicles and the groin and sealing them with stitches, knots or heat
The procedure usually takes place under local anaesthetic and is not considered effective for 2-3 months. The testes and penis are not affected, so there is no change in libido, virility or ejaculation
Vasectomy was designed in the 19th century to control sections of society such as “delinquents, degenerates, drug habitués and idiots”. It came into common use for family planning in the late 1960s